Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 225
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with 50/50
conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas
powered chainsaws ?

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear and
thin out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and
occasional downed trees from my parents wooded property ( there is
about 2 acres of overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight,
Poulan, ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with
prices from 149 - 499.

I would like to stick to lower end prices.

Is there a best of the cheap ?

thanks for helpful replies,
robb

  #2   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 618
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

"robb" wrote in message
m...

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear and thin
out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and occasional downed
trees from my parents wooded property ( there is about 2 acres of
overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight, Poulan,
ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with prices from
149 - 499.


For just this task I had earlier a 16" Husqvarna and then
a 20" Poulan, both of which were troublesome (and one
died). Five years ago I bought (used) a 14" Stihl which
does more work, is lighter thus easier to handle, and starts
and runs trouble-free.

--
Don Phillipson
Carlsbad Springs
(Ottawa, Canada)


  #3   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,055
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?


"robb" wrote in message
m...
I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with 50/50
conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas
powered chainsaws ?

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear and
thin out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and
occasional downed trees from my parents wooded property ( there is
about 2 acres of overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight,
Poulan, ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with
prices from 149 - 499.

I would like to stick to lower end prices.

Is there a best of the cheap ?

thanks for helpful replies,
robb

This is a troll, right? Best and cheap cannot be used in the same sentence.
Except by me.

Steve


  #4   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,025
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?


"robb" wrote in
I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with 50/50
conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas powered
chainsaws ?


So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight, Poulan,
ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with prices from
149 - 499.

I would like to stick to lower end prices.


Do you want to buy one saw or two? If the answer is one, buy a Stihl or
Husq.

The alternative is to buy a cheap saw now and the good saw after you get
frustrated with the junk and buy a good one next time. If you want a
Homelight, look in the wood near me where I tossed it after it did not start
again..

  #5   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,848
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

robb wrote:
I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with 50/50
conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas
powered chainsaws ?

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear and
thin out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and
occasional downed trees from my parents wooded property ( there is
about 2 acres of overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight,
Poulan, ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with
prices from 149 - 499.


Avoid Poulan, Homelight. Probably Ryobi too. You didn't ask but avoid
Sears too.

Maybe, Poulan Pro & Blue Max,not familiar with either.

Consider Stihl, Echo & Husqvarna
________________

I would like to stick to lower end prices.


Is there a best of the cheap ?


Yes. Go look at Stihl...
http://www.stihlusa.com/chainsaws/?g...FYEj7AodJ2qwcA

and try out the product selector link.

Stihl makes saws for varied uses but regardless of the use type, their saws
are superior.

Regarding bar length, you probably don't need 18" - 20" for what you want to
do. A 14" bar can cut a very sizeable log - up to almost 28" - and a
shorter bar means a lighter and easier to use saw.

In 2004 we had a bunch of hurricanes and wound up with 100s of tons of
trashed oak debris. I bought a 14" Stihl and there was very little I could
not cut; for the too large stuff I bought a longer bar & chain but rarely
use them.

--

dadiOH
____________________________

dadiOH's dandies v3.06...
....a help file of info about MP3s, recording from
LP/cassette and tips & tricks on this and that.
Get it at http://mysite.verizon.net/xico





  #6   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 11,538
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

robb wrote:
I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with 50/50
conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas
powered chainsaws ?

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear and
thin out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and
occasional downed trees from my parents wooded property ( there is
about 2 acres of overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight,
Poulan, ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with
prices from 149 - 499.

I would like to stick to lower end prices.

Is there a best of the cheap ?

thanks for helpful replies,
robb


I suspect you're considering "cheap" because of the anticipated, rare, use.

If I'm correct, consider an electric chain saw (and 200' of extension cord*,
possibly home-made). Unlike 2-cycle gas tools, an electric tool will not
rot, decay, or develop festering carbuncles if left sitting unused for a
year. Electric tools are binary - like a computer. They either work, or they
don't. Gas-powered tools are analog: there is a wide range of functioning
(works, mostly works, sometimes works, works only in the dark of the moon or
a high tide, doesn't work, etc.).

Build yourself a tote-box to carry the saw. Leave room for a quart of oil,
spare chain, and the tools necessary to replace/tighten the chain.

---
An acre is a square about 70' on a side. A 200' extension cord should reach
almost all of a two-acre plot. You may need a modest generator if there is
no electricity available.


  #7   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
Gil Gil is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 36
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

On 23/09/2011 5:39 PM, HeyBub wrote:
robb wrote:
I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with 50/50
conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas
powered chainsaws ?

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear and
thin out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and
occasional downed trees from my parents wooded property ( there is
about 2 acres of overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight,
Poulan, ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with
prices from 149 - 499.

I would like to stick to lower end prices.

Is there a best of the cheap ?

thanks for helpful replies,
robb


I suspect you're considering "cheap" because of the anticipated, rare, use.

If I'm correct, consider an electric chain saw (and 200' of extension cord*,
possibly home-made). Unlike 2-cycle gas tools, an electric tool will not
rot, decay, or develop festering carbuncles if left sitting unused for a
year. Electric tools are binary - like a computer. They either work, or they
don't. Gas-powered tools are analog: there is a wide range of functioning
(works, mostly works, sometimes works, works only in the dark of the moon or
a high tide, doesn't work, etc.).

Build yourself a tote-box to carry the saw. Leave room for a quart of oil,
spare chain, and the tools necessary to replace/tighten the chain.

---
An acre is a square about 70' on a side. A 200' extension cord should reach
almost all of a two-acre plot. You may need a modest generator if there is
no electricity available.


No to be picky, but you guys must have 'small' acres where you come
from. Up here, an acres measures just slightly over 208' on a side.

But, I agree with your comments about the saws. My first one was a
Homelite which lasted all of about a year and a half, or about six cords
of wood. Scraped it, bought a Stihl 290 and it just keeps on going, and
going, and...

Gil
  #8   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 17
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?


"Me" wrote in message
eb.com...
Don't cut off your hand.


My old German father always used to say "Buy it right, once.".
Buy a Stihl.
Dick in Ferris, TX


  #9   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 548
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

Dick Keats wrote:
"Me" wrote in message
eb.com...
Don't cut off your hand.


My old German father always used to say "Buy it right, once.".
Buy a Stihl.
Dick in Ferris, TX



How about a Sachs-Dolmar? That's a German saw too, and I believe they
are a little cheaper than a comparable Stihl.

-Bob
  #10   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 11,538
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

Gil wrote:
On 23/09/2011 5:39 PM, HeyBub wrote:
robb wrote:
I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with
50/50 conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas
powered chainsaws ?

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear
and thin out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and
occasional downed trees from my parents wooded property ( there is
about 2 acres of overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight,
Poulan, ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with
prices from 149 - 499.

I would like to stick to lower end prices.

Is there a best of the cheap ?

thanks for helpful replies,
robb


I suspect you're considering "cheap" because of the anticipated,
rare, use. If I'm correct, consider an electric chain saw (and 200' of
extension cord*, possibly home-made). Unlike 2-cycle gas tools, an
electric tool will not rot, decay, or develop festering carbuncles
if left sitting unused for a year. Electric tools are binary - like
a computer. They either work, or they don't. Gas-powered tools are
analog: there is a wide range of functioning (works, mostly works,
sometimes works, works only in the dark of the moon or a high tide,
doesn't work, etc.). Build yourself a tote-box to carry the saw. Leave
room for a quart
of oil, spare chain, and the tools necessary to replace/tighten the
chain. ---
An acre is a square about 70' on a side. A 200' extension cord
should reach almost all of a two-acre plot. You may need a modest
generator if there is no electricity available.


No to be picky, but you guys must have 'small' acres where you come
from. Up here, an acres measures just slightly over 208' on a side.

But, I agree with your comments about the saws. My first one was a
Homelite which lasted all of about a year and a half, or about six
cords of wood. Scraped it, bought a Stihl 290 and it just keeps on
going, and going, and...


(Slaps head). You're absolutely correct on the size of an acre. 43,560 sq
ft, or a square 208 ft on a side. Therefore, depending on the configuration
of the plot, to use an electric chainsaw the lumberjack would need an
extension cord of about 300'.

If the plot was one foot wide and 90,000 feet long, he may need an extension
cord some seventeen MILES in length, but that's hardly likely.

Still, to be prepared...




  #11   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,577
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

On Sep 24, 7:05*am, "HeyBub" wrote:





(Slaps head). You're absolutely correct on the size of an acre. 43,560 sq
ft, or a square 208 ft on a side. Therefore, depending on the configuration
of the plot, to use an electric chainsaw the lumberjack would need an
extension cord of about 300'.

If the plot was one foot wide and 90,000 feet long, he may need an extension
cord some seventeen MILES in length, but that's hardly likely.

Still, to be prepared...


Save all the math...and cord...buy a generator!
  #12   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,055
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?


"HeyBub" wrote

If the plot was one foot wide and 90,000 feet long, he may need an
extension cord some seventeen MILES in length, but that's hardly likely.

Still, to be prepared...


Main problem with electric cars. Cars no problem, but 250 mile cord was.

Steve


  #13   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,482
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

on 9/24/2011 8:05 AM (ET) HeyBub wrote the following:
Gil wrote:
On 23/09/2011 5:39 PM, HeyBub wrote:
robb wrote:
I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with
50/50 conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas
powered chainsaws ?

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear
and thin out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and
occasional downed trees from my parents wooded property ( there is
about 2 acres of overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight,
Poulan, ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with
prices from 149 - 499.

I would like to stick to lower end prices.

Is there a best of the cheap ?

thanks for helpful replies,
robb

I suspect you're considering "cheap" because of the anticipated,
rare, use. If I'm correct, consider an electric chain saw (and 200' of
extension cord*, possibly home-made). Unlike 2-cycle gas tools, an
electric tool will not rot, decay, or develop festering carbuncles
if left sitting unused for a year. Electric tools are binary - like
a computer. They either work, or they don't. Gas-powered tools are
analog: there is a wide range of functioning (works, mostly works,
sometimes works, works only in the dark of the moon or a high tide,
doesn't work, etc.). Build yourself a tote-box to carry the saw. Leave
room for a quart
of oil, spare chain, and the tools necessary to replace/tighten the
chain. ---
An acre is a square about 70' on a side. A 200' extension cord
should reach almost all of a two-acre plot. You may need a modest
generator if there is no electricity available.


No to be picky, but you guys must have 'small' acres where you come
from. Up here, an acres measures just slightly over 208' on a side.

But, I agree with your comments about the saws. My first one was a
Homelite which lasted all of about a year and a half, or about six
cords of wood. Scraped it, bought a Stihl 290 and it just keeps on
going, and going, and...


(Slaps head). You're absolutely correct on the size of an acre. 43,560 sq
ft, or a square 208 ft on a side. Therefore, depending on the configuration
of the plot, to use an electric chainsaw the lumberjack would need an
extension cord of about 300'.

If the plot was one foot wide and 90,000 feet long, he may need an extension
cord some seventeen MILES in length, but that's hardly likely.

Still, to be prepared...



There's also the DC to AC power inverters that can be hooked up to the
car to run the electric chainsaw. You just have to drive the car close
to the work site.


--

Bill
In Hamptonburgh, NY
In the original Orange County. Est. 1683
To email, remove the double zeroes after @
  #14   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 548
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

willshak wrote:
on 9/24/2011 8:05 AM (ET) HeyBub wrote the following:


If the plot was one foot wide and 90,000 feet long, he may need an
extension
cord some seventeen MILES in length, but that's hardly likely.

Still, to be prepared...



There's also the DC to AC power inverters that can be hooked up to the
car to run the electric chainsaw. You just have to drive the car close
to the work site.




It would take a pretty big inverter. 400W to 600W is a nice size
inverter to keep in your truck for powering lights and stuff like that,
but it wouldn't pull even a tiny saw.

Those little Remington electric chainsaws you can buy for less than $100
will get the job done, but boy do they suck to use (I have one.) Very
uncomfortable to hold, and they don't have an oil pump. The oil is
gravity-fed. All the time. Including when the saw is in storage. I
have some professional non-safety chains for another saw that just
happen to fit the Remington; I should put one on and see if that makes
it less of a pain to use.

Stihl makes several electric saws (MSE-180, MSE-220, etc) as do other
pro saw makers. That might be a good option. One good thing about an
electric is you can use it indoors.

-Bob
  #16   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,378
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

On Fri, 23 Sep 2011 10:07:38 -0400, "robb" wrote:

I have done the google searches. Now the internet is filled with 50/50
conflicting advice and reviews.

Does anyone her have experience with the big retailer brand gas
powered chainsaws ?

I am looking for probably 18"- 20" gas powered chainsaw to clear and
thin out some under brush, saplings, scrub oaks, limbs and
occasional downed trees from my parents wooded property ( there is
about 2 acres of overgrown wooded area they want cleaned up ) .

So, i was looking at the big box DIY stores and i see Homelight,
Poulan, ECHO, Stihl, Blue Max, Ryobi, Poulan Pro, Husqvarna with
prices from 149 - 499.

I would like to stick to lower end prices.

Is there a best of the cheap ?

thanks for helpful replies,
robb


When my 30 year old Poulan bit the dust I bought a small Echo like
Home Depot sells. It's about a 14" bar length. The thing I don't like
about it is that it uses a much narrower chain then the poulan did
which has made it very easy for the chain to come off at the slightest
twisting of the bar while cutting if there is even the least amount of
looseness in the chain. Never had the problem with the Poulan. So if
I was in the market again I'd pay attention to the chain width. Othr
then that the Echo seems fine for my occasional use.
  #17   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,577
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

On Sep 25, 5:28*pm, wrote:



*I find a full tank works just fine from year to year, as the tank on
the Remington is SEALED.


Maybe you have a longer cutting season than most?! B^)

  #18   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 18,538
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

On Wed, 28 Sep 2011 04:45:01 -0700 (PDT), Bob_Villa
wrote:

On Sep 25, 5:28Â*pm, wrote:



Â*I find a full tank works just fine from year to year, as the tank on
the Remington is SEALED.


Maybe you have a longer cutting season than most?! B^)

There have been yearswhere it has not even been started, much less
used a tank of fuel - and it still started the next year.
  #19   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,577
Default chainsaw reccomendation or advice ?

On Sep 28, 5:13*pm, wrote:
On Wed, 28 Sep 2011 04:45:01 -0700 (PDT), Bob_Villa

wrote:
On Sep 25, 5:28*pm, wrote:


*I find a full tank works just fine from year to year, as the tank on
the Remington is SEALED.


Maybe you have a longer cutting season than most?! B^)


* There have been years where it has not even been started, much less
used a tank of fuel - and it still started the next year.


Oh, see the smiley at the end...maybe he was trying to be amusing! he
he
Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
chainsaw reccomendation or advice ? robb Home Repair 31 September 26th 11 12:26 AM
Looking for chainsaw advice StephenM[_2_] Woodturning 9 February 10th 09 11:43 PM
Chainsaw advice william kossack Woodturning 2 December 12th 06 08:36 PM
Chainsaw advice Ralph E Lindberg Woodturning 6 December 7th 06 10:07 PM
Chainsaw advice George Woodturning 0 December 6th 06 12:29 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:14 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"