Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house
and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. Thanks in advance for help. Frank |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
On Oct 31, 10:24*pm, frank1492 wrote:
I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. * * * I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. * * *Thanks in advance for help. * * * * * Frank I do it every year and am ok, If she isnt living there draining pipes anyway is smart since heating systems do break, if its a boiler with radiators depending on how pipes are run, it may ruin pipes by turning down the system if boiler pipes are are close to exterior walls and freeze on the coldest nights. |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
On Oct 31, 10:24*pm, frank1492 wrote:
I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. * * * I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. * * *Thanks in advance for help. * * * * * Frank Some real estate sales folks are reluctant to show a cold house for sale in the winter. It always makes a potential buyer suspicious that a major problem exists in the heating system. The experts prefer a cool, 55-60F house for a walk through. The client will stay longer and take more interest in sizing up the property. IMO the plaster cracking notion is bogus and the statement was made with some other intent than being helpful; or perhaps just hearsay from some poor soul who happened to live through such an experience in a very badly built house. Joe |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
frank1492 wrote:
I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. Thanks in advance for help. Freezing temps alone will not crack your plaster. BUT. . . . No way would I shut the heat off in a house I was selling. I want the most comfortable house for both agents and buyers to visit. I *don't want little surprises when I turn the water back on- leaky valves, busted pipes that didn't get drained, cracked toilet tanks. The wonderful smell of 3 month old pee from someone peeing in a toilet that wont flush. A furnace that is now balking because it sat idle for so long. By the time you pay a plumber to properly drain all those pipes- even if nothing goes wrong- you can probably buy enough fuel to keep a closed up house at 50 degrees or so. I *would* suggest a remote readable thermostat that calls if the temp drops to dangerous levels. I haven't ever researched them but my B-I-L has one. He can call it an hour before he reaches the camp so it is nice and toasty when he gets there. The cost will be made up for in peace of mind and the 'wow' factor when she gives the number to the realtor. Jim |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
On Nov 1, 7:07�am, Jim Elbrecht wrote:
frank1492 wrote: I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. � � �I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. � � Thanks in advance for help. Freezing temps alone will not crack your plaster. � � BUT.. . . . No way would I shut the heat off in a house I was selling. I want the most comfortable house for both agents and buyers to visit. I *don't want little surprises when I turn the water back on- leaky valves, busted pipes that didn't get drained, cracked toilet tanks. The wonderful smell of 3 month old pee from someone peeing in a toilet that wont flush. A furnace that is now balking because it sat idle for so long. By the time you pay a plumber to properly drain all those pipes- even if nothing goes wrong- you can probably buy enough fuel to keep a closed up house at 50 degrees or so. I *would* suggest a remote readable thermostat that calls if the temp drops to dangerous levels. � �I haven't ever researched them but my B-I-L has one. �He can call it an hour before he reaches �the camp so it is nice and toasty when he gets there. � � � � The cost will be made up for in peace of mind and the 'wow' factor when she gives the number to the realtor. Jim I have personally seen plaster crack from expansion and contraction. the old pittsburgh airport had a severe case of that after the heat was bturned off in most areas. they had thought of turning the building into a aircraft museum. one stumbling block was repairing millions in cracked peeling plaster, it spalls and falls off. made worse by colder temperatures combined with higher humidity when heat is turned off. moisture is trapped in plaster, when the moisture freezes it expands, and plaster spalls. I sold a vacant home years ago, kept it around 50 degrees, with light that would flash if it got below 40, light was in window. neighbors kept look out for flashing light. i shut the main water valve so a leak couldnt flood anything. a freezing house discourages shppers from spending time, which is necessary for sale. dont shut off heat. owner might be better off to get a friend or realtive to live in home for free, just pay utilities. vacant homes are a major vandal arson target. have they notified the homeowners insurance? it costs many times more to insure a vacant home, and with heat off theres no way to claim anyone was living there |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
frank1492 wrote:
I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. Thanks in advance for help. Frank If she is interested in selling the house she needs to keep the heat on to at least have the place warm for showing. Prospective buyers will quickly turn their backs if they are shown it in deep freeze mode where people will have chattering teeth and the florescent lights are blinking like a horror show. |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
" wrote:
-snip- owner might be better off to get a friend or realtive to live in home for free, just pay utilities. Best plan of all if you can do it. Think post-grad or mature college kid-- or a 20something that wants t leave momma's house. Jim |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
"George" wrote in message ... frank1492 wrote: I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. Thanks in advance for help. Frank If she is interested in selling the house she needs to keep the heat on to at least have the place warm for showing. Prospective buyers will quickly turn their backs if they are shown it in deep freeze mode where people will have chattering teeth and the florescent lights are blinking like a horror show. The freezing shouldn't hurt the plaster per say BUT the moisture isn't good for alot of things including the plaster , especially if it is already bad..In the NE winters tend to be cold and WET....Nothing smells worse than an cold damp musty house...Not good for the wallpaper or paint either .... |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
I agree - moisture and condensation would be more of a concern for me in
this situation than the risk of cracks. "benick" wrote in message . .. "George" wrote in message ... frank1492 wrote: I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. Thanks in advance for help. Frank If she is interested in selling the house she needs to keep the heat on to at least have the place warm for showing. Prospective buyers will quickly turn their backs if they are shown it in deep freeze mode where people will have chattering teeth and the florescent lights are blinking like a horror show. The freezing shouldn't hurt the plaster per say BUT the moisture isn't good for alot of things including the plaster , especially if it is already bad..In the NE winters tend to be cold and WET....Nothing smells worse than an cold damp musty house...Not good for the wallpaper or paint either .... |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
Mark wrote:
I agree - moisture and condensation would be more of a concern for me in this situation than the risk of cracks. Can cracks be caused by the house structure expanding due to moisture in an unheated house? |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
On Nov 2, 3:15�am, "Bob F" wrote:
Mark wrote: I agree - moisture and condensation would be more of a concern for me in this situation than the risk of cracks. Can cracks be caused by the house structure expanding due to moisture in an unheated house? yeah not just moisture in plaster but structure too. ever hear a old home make noise? creaking sound when heat is raised a lot? a home for sale needs heat, avalkiable water etc |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
The way the post was worded I can understand why many of you focused
on the issue of selling the house, but it is unlikely for a number of reasons that the house will be put on the market before spring. I guess there are mixed opinions about the likelihood of cracks developing from lack of heat. I had hoped for a consensus discounting the idea as I favor shutting the heat off and draining the hydronic system. Without this, there clearly needs to be a remote alarm system if the inside temp falls below freezing, but I have seen those fail to alert the monitor fast enough when temps are falling rapidly. A neighbor of mine who goes to Florida had two floods- now he drains everything and shuts off the boiler. Thanks all for your comments! Frank On Sat, 31 Oct 2009 21:29:11 -0700 (PDT), ransley wrote: On Oct 31, 10:24*pm, frank1492 wrote: I think this theory is incorrect. My GF is selling her mother's house and is reluctant to shut down the heat and drain the pipes over the winter. (We live in the Northeast.) She was told by an "expert" that the plaster will crack. I regularly shut my heat off for the winter at my summer home, and have never had cracks in my plaster ceilings. * * * I'd like your comments. Obviously sudden temperature changes might do it, but not one slow drop. * * *Thanks in advance for help. * * * * * Frank I do it every year and am ok, If she isnt living there draining pipes anyway is smart since heating systems do break, if its a boiler with radiators depending on how pipes are run, it may ruin pipes by turning down the system if boiler pipes are are close to exterior walls and freeze on the coldest nights. |
Cracks in Plaster Due to Very Cold Temperatures
A house with old, horse hair plaster will definitely experience extensive hair line cracking if heat is turned off during winter months in upstate NY. I had this happen and it is major issue if you want to winterize and leave home for winter to fo the snow bird southern escape.
Possible that more modern plaster mixes do better but dont risk it with 1800s built homes!!! Trust me on this - thousands of cracks had to be v-notched and repaired! |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:08 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 DIYbanter