how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

Our house is pretty old, built in the late 1800's. Over time, the back
of the house (as well as our neighbors') has subsided a bit. Hasn't
caused any foundation problems, but it does mean that in places water
doesn't flow off the roof quite like it's supposed to anymore.

One problem is as shown in the photos linked to above. The built-in
gutter doesn't work anymore, and the water pools in a corner of the
roof (above the porch), flows over the side onto our deck, causing a
bit of damage including allowing mold and moss to grow where it
shouldn't.

How would you fix this?

I can see at least two ways:

1. Build a kind of dam using a plank of pressure-treated wood along
the side of the roof, so that water is forced to once again run down
the original gutter spout. I'd install the wood, cover it with tar
paper and roofing compound, and we'd be good to go. Maybe instead of
wood I'd use some sort of large vinyl drip edge or whatever, if I
could find it. I'd try to install the wood in a way as to not pierce
the roofing material already there, so leaks can't develop.

2. Install a new gutter alongside the edge of the porch overhang. I'd
have to connect it to the main downspout (shown in the pics) or else
install a new downspout somewhere close.

Advice and opinions? Much appreciated! Thank you!

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

on 10/8/2009 7:10 AM (ET) reflex wrote the following:
See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

Our house is pretty old, built in the late 1800's. Over time, the back
of the house (as well as our neighbors') has subsided a bit. Hasn't
caused any foundation problems, but it does mean that in places water
doesn't flow off the roof quite like it's supposed to anymore.

One problem is as shown in the photos linked to above. The built-in
gutter doesn't work anymore, and the water pools in a corner of the
roof (above the porch), flows over the side onto our deck, causing a
bit of damage including allowing mold and moss to grow where it
shouldn't.

How would you fix this?

I can see at least two ways:

1. Build a kind of dam using a plank of pressure-treated wood along
the side of the roof, so that water is forced to once again run down
the original gutter spout. I'd install the wood, cover it with tar
paper and roofing compound, and we'd be good to go. Maybe instead of
wood I'd use some sort of large vinyl drip edge or whatever, if I
could find it. I'd try to install the wood in a way as to not pierce
the roofing material already there, so leaks can't develop.

2. Install a new gutter alongside the edge of the porch overhang. I'd
have to connect it to the main downspout (shown in the pics) or else
install a new downspout somewhere close.

Advice and opinions? Much appreciated! Thank you!


Install a new downspout where the water pools?

--

Bill
In Hamptonburgh, NY
In the original Orange County. Est. 1683
To email, remove the double zeroes after @

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

reflex wrote:
....

Advice and opinions? Much appreciated! Thank you!

W/ all the pictures, there's nothing of the actual structure, only the
top from which to evaluate actual situation fully.

The answer is to reestablish the slope; how is problematical w/o more
details.

The one corner expedient would be to add a downspout at that end and let
it drain both directions; not clear whether that's feasible or not.

--

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

On Oct 8, 6:10*am, reflex wrote:
See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

Our house is pretty old, built in the late 1800's. Over time, the back
of the house (as well as our neighbors') has subsided a bit. Hasn't
caused any foundation problems, but it does mean that in places water
doesn't flow off the roof quite like it's supposed to anymore.

One problem is as shown in the photos linked to above. The built-in
gutter doesn't work anymore, and the water pools in a corner of the
roof (above the porch), flows over the side onto our deck, causing a
bit of damage including allowing mold and moss to grow where it
shouldn't.

How would you fix this?

I can see at least two ways:

1. Build a kind of dam using a plank of pressure-treated wood along
the side of the roof, so that water is forced to once again run down
the original gutter spout. I'd install the wood, cover it with tar
paper and roofing compound, and we'd be good to go. Maybe instead of
wood I'd use some sort of large vinyl drip edge or whatever, if I
could find it. I'd try to install the wood in a way as to not pierce
the roofing material already there, so leaks can't develop.

2. Install a new gutter alongside the edge of the porch overhang. I'd
have to connect it to the main downspout (shown in the pics) or else
install a new downspout somewhere close.

Advice and opinions? Much appreciated! Thank you!

Is that a pipe support because its sinking, so if it was jacked up it
would drain. Is there other damage like pulling away from house. Many
abandon old gutters like these because of leaks and rot.

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

On Oct 8, 4:10*am, reflex wrote:
See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

Our house is pretty old, built in the late 1800's. Over time, the back
of the house (as well as our neighbors') has subsided a bit. Hasn't
caused any foundation problems, but it does mean that in places water
doesn't flow off the roof quite like it's supposed to anymore.

One problem is as shown in the photos linked to above. The built-in
gutter doesn't work anymore, and the water pools in a corner of the
roof (above the porch), flows over the side onto our deck, causing a
bit of damage including allowing mold and moss to grow where it
shouldn't.

How would you fix this?

I can see at least two ways:

1. Build a kind of dam using a plank of pressure-treated wood along
the side of the roof, so that water is forced to once again run down
the original gutter spout. I'd install the wood, cover it with tar
paper and roofing compound, and we'd be good to go. Maybe instead of
wood I'd use some sort of large vinyl drip edge or whatever, if I
could find it. I'd try to install the wood in a way as to not pierce
the roofing material already there, so leaks can't develop.

2. Install a new gutter alongside the edge of the porch overhang. I'd
have to connect it to the main downspout (shown in the pics) or else
install a new downspout somewhere close.

Advice and opinions? Much appreciated! Thank you!

Your detail / closeup photos are good but the overall situation needs
on context.....you need to provide global photos shot from the
"normal" human perspective. Bird's eye views are difficuult to
undersand without having seen the "overall" picture.

cheers
Bob

oriignal question.....based on limited input, add a douwnspout, But
I'm guessing oyu have some rot / structural issues that of hand in
hand with the gutter / drainage problem

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

"reflex" wrote in message
...

See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

Our house is pretty old, built in the late 1800's. Over time, the back
of the house (as well as our neighbors') has subsided a bit. Hasn't
caused any foundation problems, but it does mean that in places water
doesn't flow off the roof quite like it's supposed to anymore.

One problem is as shown in the photos linked to above. The built-in
gutter doesn't work anymore, and the water pools in a corner of the
roof (above the porch), flows over the side onto our deck, causing a
bit of damage including allowing mold and moss to grow where it
shouldn't.

How would you fix this?

I can see at least two ways:

1. Build a kind of dam using a plank of pressure-treated wood along
the side of the roof, so that water is forced to once again run down
the original gutter spout. I'd install the wood, cover it with tar
paper and roofing compound, and we'd be good to go. Maybe instead of
wood I'd use some sort of large vinyl drip edge or whatever, if I
could find it. I'd try to install the wood in a way as to not pierce
the roofing material already there, so leaks can't develop.

2. Install a new gutter alongside the edge of the porch overhang. I'd
have to connect it to the main downspout (shown in the pics) or else
install a new downspout somewhere close.

Advice and opinions? Much appreciated! Thank you!


Really hard to tell but it looks to me like some demolition and rebuilding
is in order. If it's as old as you say you probably have a log of rot damage
that needs to be removed. From what I can see I'd start over completely.

If you're trying to just get by until you can afford to do the job right
maybe add some drain spouts.

I've got gutter problems too. We have very large live oaks that drop crap
almost year round and I don't have any guards. I was thinking of using this
but it's kind of expensive and I'm not sure if it's the answer.

http://tinyurl.com/y8ay5l2

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

On Oct 8, 11:22*am, "Master Betty" wrote:
"reflex" wrote in message

...







See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

Our house is pretty old, built in the late 1800's. Over time, the back
of the house (as well as our neighbors') has subsided a bit. Hasn't
caused any foundation problems, but it does mean that in places water
doesn't flow off the roof quite like it's supposed to anymore.

One problem is as shown in the photos linked to above. The built-in
gutter doesn't work anymore, and the water pools in a corner of the
roof (above the porch), flows over the side onto our deck, causing a
bit of damage including allowing mold and moss to grow where it
shouldn't.

How would you fix this?

I can see at least two ways:

1. Build a kind of dam using a plank of pressure-treated wood along
the side of the roof, so that water is forced to once again run down
the original gutter spout. I'd install the wood, cover it with tar
paper and roofing compound, and we'd be good to go. Maybe instead of
wood I'd use some sort of large vinyl drip edge or whatever, if I
could find it. I'd try to install the wood in a way as to not pierce
the roofing material already there, so leaks can't develop.

2. Install a new gutter alongside the edge of the porch overhang. I'd
have to connect it to the main downspout (shown in the pics) or else
install a new downspout somewhere close.

Advice and opinions? Much appreciated! Thank you!

Really hard to tell but it looks to me like some demolition and rebuilding
is in order. If it's as old as you say you probably have a log of rot damage
that needs to be removed. From what I can see I'd start over completely.

If you're trying to just get by until you can afford to do the job right
maybe add some drain spouts.

I've got gutter problems too. We have very large live oaks that drop crap
almost year round and I don't have any guards. I was thinking of using this
but it's kind of expensive and I'm not sure if it's the answer.

http://tinyurl.com/y8ay5l2- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

It looks like this sponge-like material would eventually clog also. I
have the plastic material/cover that snaps onto the outer edge of the
gutter and slightly under the bottom row of shingles and has 1/4 inch
holes. It comes with or without a screening material on the
underside. I have the kind without the screening and fine stuff does
go through into the gutter, but a good rain storm washes all that sort
of thing into the downspout and onto the grass. My neighbor has the
cover material with the screening and it clogs up, so that is why I
think the sponge-like material would eventually (like in 12 months)
clog up.

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

"hr(bob) " wrote in message
...
On Oct 8, 11:22 am, "Master Betty" wrote:
"reflex" wrote in message

...







See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

Our house is pretty old, built in the late 1800's. Over time, the back
of the house (as well as our neighbors') has subsided a bit. Hasn't
caused any foundation problems, but it does mean that in places water
doesn't flow off the roof quite like it's supposed to anymore.

One problem is as shown in the photos linked to above. The built-in
gutter doesn't work anymore, and the water pools in a corner of the
roof (above the porch), flows over the side onto our deck, causing a
bit of damage including allowing mold and moss to grow where it
shouldn't.

How would you fix this?

I can see at least two ways:

1. Build a kind of dam using a plank of pressure-treated wood along
the side of the roof, so that water is forced to once again run down
the original gutter spout. I'd install the wood, cover it with tar
paper and roofing compound, and we'd be good to go. Maybe instead of
wood I'd use some sort of large vinyl drip edge or whatever, if I
could find it. I'd try to install the wood in a way as to not pierce
the roofing material already there, so leaks can't develop.

2. Install a new gutter alongside the edge of the porch overhang. I'd
have to connect it to the main downspout (shown in the pics) or else
install a new downspout somewhere close.

Advice and opinions? Much appreciated! Thank you!

Really hard to tell but it looks to me like some demolition and rebuilding
is in order. If it's as old as you say you probably have a log of rot
damage
that needs to be removed. From what I can see I'd start over completely.

If you're trying to just get by until you can afford to do the job right
maybe add some drain spouts.

I've got gutter problems too. We have very large live oaks that drop crap
almost year round and I don't have any guards. I was thinking of using
this
but it's kind of expensive and I'm not sure if it's the answer.

http://tinyurl.com/y8ay5l2- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

It looks like this sponge-like material would eventually clog also. I
have the plastic material/cover that snaps onto the outer edge of the
gutter and slightly under the bottom row of shingles and has 1/4 inch
holes. It comes with or without a screening material on the
underside. I have the kind without the screening and fine stuff does
go through into the gutter, but a good rain storm washes all that sort
of thing into the downspout and onto the grass. My neighbor has the
cover material with the screening and it clogs up, so that is why I
think the sponge-like material would eventually (like in 12 months)
clog up.

++++++++++

Yeah...that was my thought. We just got new singles and a bunch of the
gravel is coming off too. I was just trying to take the easy way out. One of
my gutters is pooling. Standard "puncture" gutters. Is there some trick to
preventing? Seems unlikely since they are nailed into the trim. I think I
need new gutters too.

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

On Thu, 08 Oct 2009 08:05:47 -0400, willshak
wrote:

on 10/8/2009 7:10 AM (ET) reflex wrote the following:
See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

....


Install a new downspout where the water pools?

Ya beat me to it. That's my answer too.

how would you fix this gutter problem?
 

"reflex" wrote in message
...

See photos at:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/43253095@N04/

Our house is pretty old, built in the late 1800's. Over time, the back
of the house (as well as our neighbors') has subsided a bit. .

One problem is as shown in the photos linked to above. The built-in
gutter doesn't work anymore, and the water pools in a corner of the
roof (above the porch), flows over the side onto our deck, causing a
bit of damage including allowing mold and moss to grow where it
shouldn't.

snip

How would you fix this?
snip

You certainly have more problems than a bit of subsidence and water pooling
in the wrong place, reflex. If you look at photo ...121, you can see the
rotten wood on the corner. But it goes deeper as evidenced by the way the
corner post is crushing up into what looks to be a piece of aluminum, and
quit a bit too. That's why the water collect in that corner. Since the
porch roof is collapsing I'd look into that as well. At least as a
temporary patch to get you through the winter.