Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
Hi,
I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulation http://www.applegateinsulation.com and estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
On Nov 23, 11:21*pm, Aaron Fude wrote:
Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulationhttp://www.applegateinsulation.com and estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. *It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron No experiance but the cellulose said it has glue which I have read is the way to go as its applied damp and doesnt settle. Is that aplied damp. Cellulose doesnt loose R value at extreme cold like fiberglass. But the price is alot for a small job. Open houses are done for not much more. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
Yes, that is the 'wet sprayed' cellulose. It won't settle, and it is the
best insulation for the buck. Also blocks air infiltration. And is fire resistant. s "Aaron Fude" wrote in message ... Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulation http://www.applegateinsulation.com and estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
Aaron Fude wrote:
Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulation http://www.applegateinsulation.com and estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron YOU can install fiberglass batts for a piddly amount (guessing less than $200). Do you really need the extreme insulation that the bids reflect? |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
On Nov 23, 9:21*pm, Aaron Fude wrote:
Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulationhttp://www.applegateinsulation.com and estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. *It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron Aaron- Wet sprayed cellulose: does have a higher R-value than fiberglass seals up the cavity better than fiberglass does not rquire a vapor barrier (per mfr suggestion) it takes a long time to dry out studies have shown about a 20 to 30% improvement in "overall insulation" performance so it is better than fiberglass DIY fiberglass is a lot cheaper than spray cellulose or foam. If I had an open attic & was in the market for insualtion I'd go with spray cellulose. I forgot where you're located so do you really need super wall insulation? Foamboard (DIY install) could get you up to R-18/21 but the stuff ain't cheap. cheers Bob |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
You don't say if you're interested in doing this your self...but DAGS
for Mooney Wall....yes it's an odd name. It's a wall insulating method between the wet cellulose and cellulose after rocking...it's worth looking into... |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
On Nov 24, 9:40*am, "HeyBub" wrote:
Aaron Fude wrote: Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulation http://www.applegateinsulation.comand estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. *It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron YOU can install fiberglass batts for a piddly amount (guessing less than $200). Do you really need the extreme insulation that the bids reflect?- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - The cellulose is hardly better than fiberglass, foam is alot better, but those prices are no deal he is quoted. |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
BobK207 wrote:
On Nov 23, 9:21 pm, Aaron Fude wrote: Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulationhttp://www.applegateinsulation.com and estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron Aaron- Wet sprayed cellulose: does have a higher R-value than fiberglass seals up the cavity better than fiberglass does not rquire a vapor barrier (per mfr suggestion) it takes a long time to dry out studies have shown about a 20 to 30% improvement in "overall insulation" performance so it is better than fiberglass DIY fiberglass is a lot cheaper than spray cellulose or foam. If I had an open attic & was in the market for insualtion I'd go with spray cellulose. I forgot where you're located so do you really need super wall insulation? Foamboard (DIY install) could get you up to R-18/21 but the stuff ain't cheap. But he says it's for a kitchen, which I assume is situated on an exterior wall. That said, how big could it be? If he shares a 16' wall with the outside, we're talking about 16 2x4' batts or 128 sq ft of foamboard. Still less than $200. |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
On Nov 24, 12:40*pm, "HeyBub" wrote:
BobK207 wrote: On Nov 23, 9:21 pm, Aaron Fude wrote: Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulationhttp://www.applegateinsulation.comand estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron Aaron- Wet sprayed cellulose: does have a higher R-value than fiberglass seals up the cavity better than fiberglass does not rquire a vapor barrier (per mfr suggestion) it takes a long time to dry out studies have shown about a 20 to 30% improvement in "overall insulation" performance so it is better than fiberglass DIY fiberglass is a lot cheaper than spray cellulose or foam. * *If I had an open attic & was in the market for insualtion I'd go with spray cellulose. I forgot where you're located so do you really need super wall insulation? Foamboard (DIY install) could get you up to R-18/21 * but the stuff ain't cheap. But he says it's for a kitchen, which I assume is situated on an exterior wall. That said, how big could it be? If he shares a 16' wall with the outside, we're talking about 16 2x4' batts or 128 sq ft of foamboard. Still less than $200. Bub- I would agree but I figured more like 30' of outside wall (I assumed a "corner" location. worst case" and I was thinking the R-6.5(?) isocynuarte ? foam more $'s cheers Bob |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
fiberglass is practically worthless unless ALL the stud spacings are
perfect, he has no small cavities to fill and no windows and doors to work around. s "HeyBub" wrote in message m... Aaron Fude wrote: Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulation http://www.applegateinsulation.com and estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron YOU can install fiberglass batts for a piddly amount (guessing less than $200). Do you really need the extreme insulation that the bids reflect? |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
Very good answer and comparison.
steve "BobK207" wrote in message ... Aaron- Wet sprayed cellulose: does have a higher R-value than fiberglass seals up the cavity better than fiberglass does not rquire a vapor barrier (per mfr suggestion) it takes a long time to dry out studies have shown about a 20 to 30% improvement in "overall insulation" performance so it is better than fiberglass DIY fiberglass is a lot cheaper than spray cellulose or foam. If I had an open attic & was in the market for insualtion I'd go with spray cellulose. I forgot where you're located so do you really need super wall insulation? Foamboard (DIY install) could get you up to R-18/21 but the stuff ain't cheap. cheers Bob |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
Aaron Fude wrote:
Hi, I have received five estimates for inslulating my kitchen (whose walls are currently open) ranging from $840 (cellulose upon completing the walls) to $2500 (high density, closed cell foam). The estimator I felt the most comfortable with was representing a product made by Applegate Insulation http://www.applegateinsulation.com and estimating the job at $1075. Does anybody have any experience or openion on this company. It looks like cellulose applied kind of like foam. Many thanks in advance, Aaron If walls are open, and if you are only insulating the walls, cheapest by far is fiberglass bats from the big box, installed by you. Unless you live in a real cold climate, and if you do a careful job, the fancy expanding foam will never pay back in your lifetime. Yeah, it is best, but it costs several times what fiberglass does. Cellulose in walls tends to sag, even the 'no sag' formulations. (IMHO, of course.) -- aem sends... |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
properly installed, stabilized cellulose, does not 'sag'....
s "aemeijers" wrote in message ... Cellulose in walls tends to sag, even the 'no sag' formulations. (IMHO, of course.) -- aem sends... |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
Steve Barker DLT wrote:
properly installed, stabilized cellulose, does not 'sag'.... s "aemeijers" wrote in message ... Cellulose in walls tends to sag, even the 'no sag' formulations. (IMHO, of course.) -- aem sends... If you say so. How is the average homeowner to know if it is properly installed? I've opened plenty of walls where there was a BIG gap at the top. A buddy of mine back home with a 2 year old mcmansion has cold wall tops in a couple upstairs bedrooms. Yes, I've seen the demo walls at the home shows, set up by the insulation companies. Call me old fashioned, I guess- I don't trust new stuff till it has been around a few decades. If I had a kitchen with open walls, I'd use fiberglass with a good vapor barrier, and pocket the cost difference. -- aem sends... |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Help with insulation choice.
Well you can't install 'stabilized' cellulose with the walls intact. I can
tell you that much. It has to be done to the open studs. I have some that was put in place 2 years ago, that i still haven't covered, and it's still just as tight as the day it dried. steve "aemeijers" wrote in message ... Steve Barker DLT wrote: properly installed, stabilized cellulose, does not 'sag'.... s "aemeijers" wrote in message ... Cellulose in walls tends to sag, even the 'no sag' formulations. (IMHO, of course.) -- aem sends... If you say so. How is the average homeowner to know if it is properly installed? I've opened plenty of walls where there was a BIG gap at the top. A buddy of mine back home with a 2 year old mcmansion has cold wall tops in a couple upstairs bedrooms. Yes, I've seen the demo walls at the home shows, set up by the insulation companies. Call me old fashioned, I guess- I don't trust new stuff till it has been around a few decades. If I had a kitchen with open walls, I'd use fiberglass with a good vapor barrier, and pocket the cost difference. -- aem sends... |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|