Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
Can someone tell me if the Canadian electrical code requires an ground
wire to be connected to a light switch, I always connected the ground to the box, but a fellow electrician just told me they now need to be screwed onto the switch. |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
On Nov 30, 3:33 pm, Waylon wrote:
Can someone tell me if the Canadian electrical code requires an ground wire to be connected to a light switch, I always connected the ground to the box, but a fellow electrician just told me they now need to be screwed onto the switch. Maybe they changed it to make it more "one size fits all" Consider metal boxes vs plastic boxes. Since the switch screws into the metal box with metal screws, grounding either grounds both. Obviously with a plastic box, the only way to ground the switch is to attach the wire to the switch. If they write the code to say that the wire must be attached to the switch, both situations would be covered without any ambiguity. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
Waylon wrote:
Can someone tell me if the Canadian electrical code requires an ground wire to be connected to a light switch, I always connected the ground to the box, but a fellow electrician just told me they now need to be screwed onto the switch. The light switches that I've dealt with do not have a ground connection...only the receptacles. Receptacles, on the other hand, normally have the ground conductor connected to the receptacle as well as the box (if the box is metal). Chris |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
"DerbyDad03" wrote in message ... On Nov 30, 3:33 pm, Waylon wrote: Can someone tell me if the Canadian electrical code requires an ground wire to be connected to a light switch, I always connected the ground to the box, but a fellow electrician just told me they now need to be screwed onto the switch. Maybe they changed it to make it more "one size fits all" Consider metal boxes vs plastic boxes. Since the switch screws into the metal box with metal screws, grounding either grounds both. Obviously with a plastic box, the only way to ground the switch is to attach the wire to the switch. If they write the code to say that the wire must be attached to the switch, both situations would be covered without any ambiguity. Canadian plastic boxes have a metal grounding strap installed to attach the grounding wire. I have personally not seen on/off switches with ground screws, but timers, X-10, scene controls and dimmers often need a ground wire. I think that ground wires "must" be attached to the box first, then connected with any other ground feedthrough wires and a pigtail (if the switch doesn't have its own pigtail) to connect to the device exactly like grounding a receptacle. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
do you have a link to a picture of a light switch that does NOT have a
ground screw on it? s "Chris Friesen" wrote in message ... Waylon wrote: Can someone tell me if the Canadian electrical code requires an ground wire to be connected to a light switch, I always connected the ground to the box, but a fellow electrician just told me they now need to be screwed onto the switch. The light switches that I've dealt with do not have a ground connection...only the receptacles. Receptacles, on the other hand, normally have the ground conductor connected to the receptacle as well as the box (if the box is metal). Chris |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
uhhhhhhh..... i was thinking new ones. I have many like you describe
myself. thanks s wrote in message news On Fri, 30 Nov 2007 23:47:40 -0600, "Steve Barker" wrote: do you have a link to a picture of a light switch that does NOT have a ground screw on it? Do you care how old it is ;-) I have some about 15- 20 years old that don't have the terminal. |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
On Fri, 30 Nov 2007 17:03:44 -0330, Waylon wrote:
Can someone tell me if the Canadian electrical code requires an ground wire to be connected to a light switch, I always connected the ground to the box, but a fellow electrician just told me they now need to be screwed onto the switch. What would be the advantage to grounding a switch? I see none. Ask your electrical inspector or an electrician about the code. A good one will be more than willing to help. Replacing a switch does not entail a permit. |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
wrote in message ... On Fri, 30 Nov 2007 15:13:52 -0600, Chris Friesen wrote: The light switches that I've dealt with do not have a ground It may just be a US thing but switches have been required to be grounded for several NEC cycles. All the ones you see for sale here have a ground terminal. Most pictures of US plastic boxes do NOT have a ground strap, so possibly they require switches to have a ground screw to anchor the ground wire and to ground the switch frame. Canadian plastic boxes have a ground strap that provides a ground screw the same as a metal box. The strap then runs up to where the devise is attached by its screw, grounding the device frame on a switch. This is probably why Canadian switches do not need a ground screw on the switch frame. |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
What would be the advantage to grounding a switch? I see none.
No reason to ground something doesn't stop them from wanting it grounded. OK, to prevent the metal part of the switch from going hot in the event of a fault. But why does my plastic bodied Dremel have a polarized plug? |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
OK, to prevent the metal part of the switch from going hot in the event of
a fault. But why does my plastic bodied Dremel have a polarized plug? Because the metal chuck at the end is not insulated from the motor. |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
Steve Barker wrote:
do you have a link to a picture of a light switch that does NOT have a ground screw on it? I must be missing something here, because neither have I ever seen a light switch with a ground terminal on it, nor can I see the utility in having a ground terminal on a light switch. But here's a link to instructions on how to wire a light switch, and said instructions don't show any ground terminals in play. http://www.electrical-online.com/bas...variation1.htm Now, as to whether the metal frame part of the switch should be grounded by contact with a grounded box, that's different. But I don't consider the part of the frame that mounts into a box to be a terminal. What am I missing here? -- Angry American flags attack Hillary Clinton! |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
You're kidding right? If not, why not try googling "light switch" and do
a couple days worth of reading. The switch is grounded for the same reason anything else is grounded. so if it shorts to the frame, YOU DON'T FRY. s Again, do you have a link to a picture of a modern light switch that does NOT have a ground screw on it? "clifto" wrote in message ... Steve Barker wrote: do you have a link to a picture of a light switch that does NOT have a ground screw on it? I must be missing something here, because neither have I ever seen a light switch with a ground terminal on it, nor can I see the utility in having a ground terminal on a light switch. But here's a link to instructions on how to wire a light switch, and said instructions don't show any ground terminals in play. http://www.electrical-online.com/bas...variation1.htm Now, as to whether the metal frame part of the switch should be grounded by contact with a grounded box, that's different. But I don't consider the part of the frame that mounts into a box to be a terminal. What am I missing here? -- Angry American flags attack Hillary Clinton! |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
do you have a link to a picture of a modern light
switch that does NOT have a ground screw on it? You can't buy them new because a ground is required by code now. However, about 15 years ago I bought a bunch of outlets and switches for a shed with extras for the garage we were going to build. When we finally got around to building the garage, I installed them, not realizing the codes (and the new switches) had changed. The inspector noticed immediately (based on my experience, grounds are the FIRST thing the inspectors look for). I don't know when the change took place, but it must have been close to the time we built our garage (2001). The inspector approved the installation anyway, saying we "probably just got an old box of switches". I doubt any inspector would allow them today. For the most part, an ungrounded switch is safe, because the cover plate is plastic and the switch handle is plastic. However, if there was a short in the switch, the screws that hold on the cover plate could be energized. It's an unlikely situation, but it could be very dangerous. Switches have ground connections. Use them. Anthony |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
Grounds have been required since WAY before 2001.
s "HerHusband" wrote in message ... do you have a link to a picture of a modern light switch that does NOT have a ground screw on it? You can't buy them new because a ground is required by code now. However, about 15 years ago I bought a bunch of outlets and switches for a shed with extras for the garage we were going to build. When we finally got around to building the garage, I installed them, not realizing the codes (and the new switches) had changed. The inspector noticed immediately (based on my experience, grounds are the FIRST thing the inspectors look for). I don't know when the change took place, but it must have been close to the time we built our garage (2001). The inspector approved the installation anyway, saying we "probably just got an old box of switches". I doubt any inspector would allow them today. For the most part, an ungrounded switch is safe, because the cover plate is plastic and the switch handle is plastic. However, if there was a short in the switch, the screws that hold on the cover plate could be energized. It's an unlikely situation, but it could be very dangerous. Switches have ground connections. Use them. Anthony |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
Steve,
Grounds have been required since WAY before 2001. I purchased the switches and outlets long before then, I'm guessing around 1990 or so. The outlets were grounded, the switches were not. In any case, you won't find the ungrounded switches for sale today, but I was just verifying that at some point ungrounded switches were commonly available. Anthony |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
|
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Ground on Light switch?
franz frippl wrote:
On Fri, 30 Nov 2007 17:03:44 -0330, Waylon wrote: Can someone tell me if the Canadian electrical code requires an ground wire to be connected to a light switch, I always connected the ground to the box, but a fellow electrician just told me they now need to be screwed onto the switch. What would be the advantage to grounding a switch? I see none. I think grounding of switches appeared in the US-NEC to provide a ground for metal plates. Switches have to be grounded by: 1 - attachment with metal screws to a metal box (or plastic box with integral grounding means). 2 - ground wire attachment to a grounding screw on the switch (used for plastic boxes). (there are exceptions) (2005NEC 404.9-B) -- bud-- |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Use ground as neutral on a switch | Home Repair | |||
Turning 3 way light switch into 1 motion sensor switch | Home Repair | |||
adding a new switch/light on to an existing 3-way switch | Home Repair | |||
Adding a single light to a dual switch light system | Home Repair | |||
how to rewire bathroom pull switch to regular light switch | UK diy |