Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

I've never used map gas for sweating copper and brass. My
understanding is that it is much hotter so is it okay for 1/2" and
3/4" copper fittings? Can I use the same flame adjuster from the
propane tank on the map gas tank? Any other advice working with map
gas? Thanks.

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

"Joseph Meehan" wrote in message
...
wrote:
I've never used map gas for sweating copper and brass. My
understanding is that it is much hotter so is it okay for 1/2" and
3/4" copper fittings? Can I use the same flame adjuster from the
propane tank on the map gas tank? Any other advice working with map
gas? Thanks.

I believe you need a different head for MAP and I am not sure it would
be the best choice for ½ inch fittings. I may be a tad too much.

--
Joseph Meehan

Dia 's Muire duit


Propane is fine for 1/2 copper fittings - at least in my limited experience.
It only takes like 20 seconds to heat a joint up - maybe 30 tops. That's
nothing. When you don't know much about soldering pipes, like myself, it
helps having a lower flame temp - too much heat and the joint is ruined
before you even get the solder on it.

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

On Mar 2, 11:16�pm, "Eigenvector" wrote:
"Joseph Meehan" wrote in message

...

wrote:
I've never used map gas for sweating copper and brass. *My
understanding is that it is much hotter so is it okay for 1/2" and
3/4" copper fittings? *Can I use the same flame adjuster from the
propane tank on the map gas tank? *Any other advice working with map
gas? *Thanks.

* *I believe you need a different head for MAP and I am not sure it would
be the best choice for ½ inch fittings. *I may be a tad too much.

--
Joseph Meehan

Dia 's Muire duit

Propane is fine for 1/2 copper fittings - at least in my limited experience.
It only takes like 20 seconds to heat a joint up - maybe 30 tops. *That's
nothing. *When you don't know much about soldering pipes, like myself, it
helps having a lower flame temp - too much heat and the joint is ruined
before you even get the solder on it.

I use mapp for 1/2 lines, it just heats faster.

you do need a different torch head, oddly enough mine mapp is non
adjustable for flame control. home depot doesnt carry a adjustable one

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

you do need a different torch head, oddly enough mine mapp is non
adjustable for flame control. home depot doesnt carry a adjustable one
--------------------------------
I use the same torch for both. It seems to work out okay.
What is the the difference?

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

Toller wrote:
you do need a different torch head, oddly enough mine mapp is non
adjustable for flame control. home depot doesnt carry a adjustable
one
--------------------------------
I use the same torch for both. It seems to work out okay.
What is the the difference?

I would guess they each require a different gas/air mixture for ideal
operation.

--
Joseph Meehan

Dia 's Muire duit

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

Toller wrote:
you do need a different torch head, oddly enough mine mapp is non
adjustable for flame control. home depot doesnt carry a adjustable
one
--------------------------------
I use the same torch for both. It seems to work out okay.
What is the the difference?

MAPP gas is made by combining liquefied petroleum gas with
Methylacetylene-Propadiene. MAPP gas burns hotter than propane. IIRC,
propane is close to 4000 degrees, while MAPP is about 5300.

You need a certain amount of heat to properly sweat a joint. If you use
propane on a 1/2" fitting, you can get there. With the lead free solder,
you need a bit more heat so MAPP gas willl get you there faster, expecialy
on larger joints. While it is possible to overheat a joint, if the flame is
hotter, you merely hold the torch a bit further away and heat it for less
time.

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

In article , says...
you do need a different torch head, oddly enough mine mapp is non
adjustable for flame control. home depot doesnt carry a adjustable one
--------------------------------
I use the same torch for both. It seems to work out okay.

Your repeated posts here about leaky plumbing suggest that it does not,
in fact, "work out okay".

What is the the difference?

MAPP is a *lot* hotter than propane.

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

In article .com,
says...
I've never used map gas for sweating copper and brass. My
understanding is that it is much hotter

That's correct.

so is it okay for 1/2" and
3/4" copper fittings?

I've never used it on 1/2", but it works fine on 3/4". I don't see any
reason why it wouldn't on 1/2" -- just be careful not to overheat the
joint. It takes only a brief exposure to a MAPP flame to heat a 3/4"
joint enough to flow solder into it. I never timed it, but my guess is
that it's on the order of eight to ten seconds.

Can I use the same flame adjuster from the
propane tank on the map gas tank?

No. MAPP will not burn properly with a propane torch head.

Any other advice working with map gas? Thanks.

If you only have a small number of joints to solder, on 1/2 and 3/4
pipe, and you already own a propane torch, there's not really much point
in buying a MAPP torch.

OTOH, if you're doing several dozen joints, or working with 1" or larger
pipe, go with MAPP. You won't regret it. You can get the work done in a
small fraction of the time that it takes with propane.

MAPP is particularly useful when working with lead-free solder, which
has a higher melting point than conventional tin-lead solder. Sometimes,
it seems like that stuff takes forever to melt, when using a propane
torch.

For anyone who does not already own a torch, and is trying to decide
between propane and MAPP, my advice is to go with MAPP. The MAPP torch
costs about $18 to $20 more, but IMO it's well worth it in the time
saved. The gas costs more per bottle, too, but I suspect that's probably
a wash in the long run, because you don't need to use nearly as much
MAPP to heat a fitting as you do propane; you may even come out ahead in
that respect with MAPP.

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

Doug Miller writes:

For anyone who does not already own a torch, and is trying to decide
between propane and MAPP, my advice is to go with MAPP. The MAPP torch
costs about $18 to $20 more, but IMO it's well worth it in the time
saved. The gas costs more per bottle, too, but I suspect that's probably
a wash in the long run, because you don't need to use nearly as much
MAPP to heat a fitting as you do propane; you may even come out ahead in
that respect with MAPP.

You may also be able to burn propane in the MAPP torch. I have a
Turner "swirl torch" that will burn either fuel; there's a regulator
adjustment you make when changing fuels. I find that it produces more
heat from propane than a regular propane torch, though not as much as
when burning MAPP. I tend to do copper pipe soldering using propane in
the swirl torch.

There was one time recently when I wished I'd switched to MAPP: I was
soldering a 1/2" side branch into a 3/4" tee. There was a brass valve
on the 1/2" pipe already, and the 3/4" tee had a brass valve on one
side and a pressure regulator on the other side, so plenty of mass to
suck heat away from the joint. And there was a slow drip of water into
the joint, which was continually being turned into steam. Despite all
this, the propane *did* get it hot enough to solder - it just took a
while.

Dave

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

In article ,
says...
In article .com,
says...

Can I use the same flame adjuster from the
propane tank on the map gas tank?

No. MAPP will not burn properly with a propane torch head.

True. But many MAPP torches will do well with propane when you don't
need as much heat. I only buy MAPP-compatible torches, even if I mostly
use them with propane.

--
is Joshua Putnam
http://www.phred.org/~josh/
Braze your own bicycle frames. See
http://www.phred.org/~josh/build/build.html

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

Someone mentioned ruining a joint due to too much heat. What exactly
happens? Does the copper just turn black and not adhere to the solder?

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

wrote in message
oups.com...
Someone mentioned ruining a joint due to too much heat. What exactly
happens? Does the copper just turn black and not adhere to the solder?

I've done it... I think you ruin the flux so it is not effective in
preventing the copper from being oxidized, as it normally would be from the
heat.

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

wrote in message
oups.com...
Someone mentioned ruining a joint due to too much heat. What exactly
happens? Does the copper just turn black and not adhere to the solder?


Pretty much, you burn out the flux and start to oxidize the surface. MAPP
get hotter faster so you have to know when to put the solder to the joint
and then take the heat away. Any torch can over heat a joint, and even
natural gas can be used to braze with if you have the right setup with
oxygen.

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

I've found to touch the solder to the joint from the very first
instant when I apply heat. When the joint is cold, it won't do
anything. Finally the joint hits the magic temperature, and the
solder flows.

My early mistake was to heat the fitting too hot, and then apply
the solder too late. I always got a pinhole leak. Now, I apply
the solder from the first instant.

Mapp gas works nicely for water copper soldering, but propane is
just fine.

--

Christopher A. Young
You can't shout down a troll.
You have to starve them.
..

"Edwin Pawlowski" wrote in message
t...
:
: Pretty much, you burn out the flux and start to oxidize the
surface. MAPP
: get hotter faster so you have to know when to put the solder to
the joint
: and then take the heat away. Any torch can over heat a joint,
and even
: natural gas can be used to braze with if you have the right
setup with
: oxygen.
:
:

Is map gas compat with propane for sweating?
 

In article .com,
wrote:

Someone mentioned ruining a joint due to too much heat. What exactly
happens? Does the copper just turn black and not adhere to the solder?

MAPP burns leaner than propane in a given torch due to lower given
volume of air needed to burn a given volume of gas fuel. MAPP can cause
bad oxidation, especially if used with a torch not rated/intended for use
with MAPP.

Also, it is possible to overheat a torch with MAPP if the torch is not
rated for use with MAPP.

Just to make things a bit more confusing, there is even an "intermediate
fuel" (my words), less common, sold with a few torches and known as
propylene. It burns leaner and typically hotter in a given torch than
propane, but richer and typically less hot than MAPP in a given torch than
MAPP. A few torches are rated for both propane and propylene but not
MAPP. Torches rated for both propane and MAPP should handle propylene
just fine, just don't go kablooey when using propylene with a torch rated
for MAPP and propane but not certified for propylene if a big legal budget
is stacked against you.
Keep in mind that in the USA the usual retail-available torches tend to
be subject to UL approval, and such approval is conditional upon use with
specific fuels that the torches are approved for use with.

- Don Klipstein )