Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a
specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. As far as I can tell, he doesn't have a leg to stand on since he gave us a quote, but I just wanted to check with other people. I'm located in Ontario, by the way. Chris |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
Chris Birkett wrote: My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. As far as I can tell, he doesn't have a leg to stand on since he gave us a quote, but I just wanted to check with other people. I'm located in Ontario, by the way. Chris I imagine it depends on the exact wording of the "quote" and the laws in your area. I have never had a tradesman actually do a job for the amount originally quoted. Its usually at leasy 20% higher for the work quoted, and opten much higher cause they "find" things that add to the cost. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
"Chris Birkett" wrote in message ps.com... My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. As far as I can tell, he doesn't have a leg to stand on since he gave us a quote, but I just wanted to check with other people. I'm located in Ontario, by the way. Chris Asking here makes about as much sense as asking us "Do you think it will rain tomorrow?" It all depends on where you live. USUALLY, though, contracts go something like this. One party offers to do work for a set amount of money. In the proposal, a good contractor says what work they will do and how much they will charge. If the work varies, the contractor MUST consult with the owner and discuss what changes from the original plan are to be made. They then agree on a CHANGE ORDER and they then do the same thing again. Describe the work and set a price. Then they both sign it. Arbitrarily changing prices doesn't fly in most places, whether it's chimney work or car repairs. At least most jurisdictions have enacted laws that prevent an owner from being held hostage by repairpeople. Check with the contractor who did the work. HE IS A CONTRACTOR, RIGHT? If not, you may have recourse in your jurisdiction. In some jurisdictions, you may just have to eat it. In mine, contracting is a felony. AND the law defines contracting also to include merely offering to do the work, even though no work was ever started or completed. Check where you live, and not on the Internet. BTW, do you think I will get rain tomorrow? Silly question, isn't it? Steve |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
Steve B wrote:
Asking here makes about as much sense as asking us "Do you think it will rain tomorrow?" It all depends on where you live. USUALLY, though, contracts go something like this. One party offers to do work for a set amount of money. In the proposal, a good contractor says what work they will do and how much they will charge. If the work varies, the contractor MUST consult with the owner and discuss what changes from the original plan are to be made. They then agree on a CHANGE ORDER and they then do the same thing again. Describe the work and set a price. Then they both sign it. Arbitrarily changing prices doesn't fly in most places, whether it's chimney work or car repairs. At least most jurisdictions have enacted laws that prevent an owner from being held hostage by repairpeople. Check with the contractor who did the work. HE IS A CONTRACTOR, RIGHT? If not, you may have recourse in your jurisdiction. In some jurisdictions, you may just have to eat it. In mine, contracting is a felony. AND the law defines contracting also to include merely offering to do the work, even though no work was ever started or completed. Check where you live, and not on the Internet. BTW, do you think I will get rain tomorrow? Silly question, isn't it? Steve I realize it's a rather general question, but even the information you gave me is useful. Can you explain more what you mean by "he is a contractor, right?" I don't know anything about him, but I will pass everything on to my dad. What you said about a "change order" makes sense. Like I said, he did find there was much more extensive damage than we previously thought, and he and my dad agreed on a new price (which was substantially higher). He did the work while my dad was in the States, and now he is claiming he had to do more than he expected and decided to go ahead and do it since my dad wasn't available to discuss it. It was not mentioned to anyone else in the house. Thanks for all your help Chris P.S. if you let me know where you are, I can probably tell you whether it's likely to rain tomorrow :P |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
Chris Birkett wrote: Steve B wrote: Asking here makes about as much sense as asking us "Do you think it will rain tomorrow?" It all depends on where you live. USUALLY, though, contracts go something like this. One party offers to do work for a set amount of money. In the proposal, a good contractor says what work they will do and how much they will charge. If the work varies, the contractor MUST consult with the owner and discuss what changes from the original plan are to be made. They then agree on a CHANGE ORDER and they then do the same thing again. Describe the work and set a price. Then they both sign it. Arbitrarily changing prices doesn't fly in most places, whether it's chimney work or car repairs. At least most jurisdictions have enacted laws that prevent an owner from being held hostage by repairpeople. Check with the contractor who did the work. HE IS A CONTRACTOR, RIGHT? If not, you may have recourse in your jurisdiction. In some jurisdictions, you may just have to eat it. In mine, contracting is a felony. AND the law defines contracting also to include merely offering to do the work, even though no work was ever started or completed. Check where you live, and not on the Internet. BTW, do you think I will get rain tomorrow? Silly question, isn't it? Steve I realize it's a rather general question, but even the information you gave me is useful. Can you explain more what you mean by "he is a contractor, right?" I don't know anything about him, but I will pass everything on to my dad. What you said about a "change order" makes sense. Like I said, he did find there was much more extensive damage than we previously thought, and he and my dad agreed on a new price (which was substantially higher). He did the work while my dad was in the States, and now he is claiming he had to do more than he expected and decided to go ahead and do it since my dad wasn't available to discuss it. It was not mentioned to anyone else in the house. Thanks for all your help Chris P.S. if you let me know where you are, I can probably tell you whether it's likely to rain tomorrow :P The contractor should not have done work that was going to cost extra without approval. However, what you fail to tell us was IF in fact the extra work that he did really was above and beyond what he had already agreed to do for a fixed price and IF it was necessary. For example, if upon taking apart the chimney he found rot that was part of the house the chimney joins to and repaired that for a fair price, then I would pay him. Of course, in many cases, it could be hard to establish exactly what he did or didn't do now that the job is completed. I would ask him to show you what exactly extra he did. If he doesn't have proof, like receipts for specific material attributable only to the extra work, then he isn't in a very good position to prevail if he tries to sue you for non-payment. You would need to establish that there was an agreed to price and that the extra work was never authorized. However, as I said, if you believe he really did the work at a fair price and it was required anyway, then I would pay him, or perhaps negotiate. |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
|
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
"Chris Birkett" wrote Can you explain more what you mean by "he is a contractor, right?" Each locality has its own rules about contracting. Contracting is when I say "I will paint your house for $1500." We have an agreement, and if we have a dispute, it goes before a board to settle the dispute. If you hire me for $15 an hour to paint your house, and at some time find that I'm not doing a good job, or you run out of money, or I start not showing up, the agreement is ended. Either party can end the agreement for just about any reason. But when there is offer and acceptance, there is a contract. If one or the other doesn't perform, there are grounds for legal action. Local laws set the rules for these situations so that homeowners don't get taken, and so that there is less litigation in the courts. They also set them so that there are some standards. For example, they test the contractor applicants in different areas to make sure they know what they're doing and that they know the laws governing the operation of a business. In my location, Las Vegas, (where it hardly rains), it is a FELONY to contract without a license, and that means to even make an offer to do work for a fixed sum. Handy men can do all they want by the hour, but if it is a permanent attachment to the house, they are supposed to have a contractor's license. This is to standardize things and help get things done up to code. You might want to investigate and see what the regs are in your area. Look in your state's directory for contractor's board, or just ask around. What you want is to get the job done and done right. But you don't want to get taken advantage of. It was one BIG assumption on the part of the worker to go ahead with a lot of extra work that wasn't authorized. That didn't even give you the chance to have others bid on it, and perhaps get it done for less. And now who's to say if the work was even needed or appropriate? And why didn't he even ask you about it, in case you may have been able to call your dad and get the okay? I smell a fish here. Steve |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
On Tue, 14 Nov 2006 16:54:59 -0800, "Steve B"
wrote: "Chris Birkett" wrote in message ups.com... My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. As far as I can tell, he doesn't have a leg to stand on since he gave us a quote, but I just wanted to check with other people. I'm located in Ontario, by the way. Do you think he did the extra work? If so, why don't you want to pay him? |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
"Chris Birkett" wrote in message
ps.com... My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. As far as I can tell, he doesn't have a leg to stand on since he gave us a quote, but I just wanted to check with other people. I'm located in Ontario, by the way. You could start with the Government of Ontario web site (Dept. of Consumer Affairs) because there may be local laws concerning estimates, oral contracts etc. -- Don Phillipson Carlsbad Springs (Ottawa, Canada) |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
Chris Birkett wrote:
My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. As far as I can tell, he doesn't have a leg to stand on since he gave us a quote, but I just wanted to check with other people. I'm located in Ontario, by the way. You're not a lawyer, eh? There's always a leg to stand on. You said your dad was in the US, so I guess he's back now. Why are you getting involved in an agreement between your father and a contractor? If your father trusted the guy to do the work while he was gone, knowing that there was no supervision, why are you second guessing him? R |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
"Chris Birkett" wrote in message ps.com... My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. As far as I can tell, he doesn't have a leg to stand on since he gave us a quote, but I just wanted to check with other people. I'm located in Ontario, by the way. Presumably this will end up in small claims court (I am making the wild assumption you have small claims courts). Judges there are more concerned with fairness than legality. If the contractor can convince the judge that he did everything properly, gave good value, and had a good reason not to have gotten approval first for the extra work, he will probably win. If he can't, he will lose. And if you think about it, if the contractor is right, he deserves to get paid, doesn't he? |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
Chris Birkett wrote: My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. Most states have a Statue of Frauds that requires all contracts for more than $500 and for Real Estate deals to be written; otherwise, courts will not enforce the contract. |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
I can't see how if he had it apart when he upped it the first time, how he
could then justify an addtional 1100 bucks, all of which would have to be labor as the cost of materials couldn't have gone up that from start to finish of the job. I'm in Canada too, lets say he charges $50.00 an hour, that's 22 hours of labor, that's 1/2 a chimneys worth on top of the original second quote. "Chris Birkett" wrote in message ps.com... My dad recently had a guy in to repair the chimney, and he quoted a specific amount for a basic repair. After he started working on it, it became obvious the chimney needed much more extensive repairs, and he gave my dad a new quote, which they agreed on. My dad was in the US for most of the time the repairs were being done, and the guy has now given him a bill that's $1100 higher than the quote, saying he had to do "extra work" and my dad wasn't available to discuss it (though my mother was here the whole time). He also hasn't done a couple of minor jobs he agreed to do at the same time. As far as I can tell, he doesn't have a leg to stand on since he gave us a quote, but I just wanted to check with other people. I'm located in Ontario, by the way. Chris |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
Greg wrote:
I can't see how if he had it apart when he upped it the first time, how he could then justify an addtional 1100 bucks, all of which would have to be labor as the cost of materials couldn't have gone up that from start to finish of the job. I'm going to take a wild stab at this and guess that you've never done any remodeling. In any event, regardless of your apparent lack of experience, you have no information to support your assumptions - certainly not enough to pass judgment. I had asked the OP a question which went unanswered. It gets to the root of the matter. If the father felt comfortable letting the contractor work unsupervised while he was out of the country, and agreed that additional work needed to be done due to unforeseen conditions, why is the son getting involved? Is he "protecting" his father or just sticking his two cents into something he doesn't understand? I'm in Canada too, lets say he charges $50.00 an hour, that's 22 hours of labor, that's 1/2 a chimneys worth on top of the original second quote. They don't charge for materials where you are? Using numbers to illustrate a bad assumption is worse than the bad assumption. Did the contractor have additional labor? I'd assume so - putting up a chimney is rarely done alone, and almost never by a contractor. Two helpers? What if there was damaged framing that needed to be replaced? Did the contractor do it himself or hire it out? You see my point. No information makes for nothing more than a guessing game. You will not get complete information from the son, as it's his opinion that the work was unnecessary and it's only one side of the story. Besides that, he wasn't part of the agreement. Did you wonder why the father didn't tag the son to be the supervision while he was away? Kind of curious, no? R |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
RicodJour wrote:
I had asked the OP a question which went unanswered. It gets to the root of the matter. If the father felt comfortable letting the contractor work unsupervised while he was out of the country, and agreed that additional work needed to be done due to unforeseen conditions, why is the son getting involved? Is he "protecting" his father or just sticking his two cents into something he doesn't understand? The real root of the matter is that he DIDN'T agree to pay for additional work. I don't see how my motivation affects this. You will not get complete information from the son, as it's his opinion that the work was unnecessary and it's only one side of the story. Besides that, he wasn't part of the agreement. Did you wonder why the father didn't tag the son to be the supervision while he was away? Kind of curious, no? I don't understand why this bothers you so much. When did I say the work was unnecessary? As it stands, the extra charge has not been justified at all, and the work has not even been completed to satisfaction. I *was* dealing with the repair people while he was gone, and additional costs were never mentioned. Both my mother and I were readily available to discuss it on any of the several days they were here, and they knew my dad was available by e-mail. Chris |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
Chris Birkett wrote: RicodJour wrote: I had asked the OP a question which went unanswered. It gets to the root of the matter. If the father felt comfortable letting the contractor work unsupervised while he was out of the country, and agreed that additional work needed to be done due to unforeseen conditions, why is the son getting involved? Is he "protecting" his father or just sticking his two cents into something he doesn't understand? The real root of the matter is that he DIDN'T agree to pay for additional work. I don't see how my motivation affects this. You will not get complete information from the son, as it's his opinion that the work was unnecessary and it's only one side of the story. Besides that, he wasn't part of the agreement. Did you wonder why the father didn't tag the son to be the supervision while he was away? Kind of curious, no? I don't understand why this bothers you so much. When did I say the work was unnecessary? As it stands, the extra charge has not been justified at all, and the work has not even been completed to satisfaction. I *was* dealing with the repair people while he was gone, and additional costs were never mentioned. Both my mother and I were readily available to discuss it on any of the several days they were here, and they knew my dad was available by e-mail. Chris Lots of sound and fury about not-much here, eh? Let's wrap this up- ask your dad to work this out with the tradesman, one-on-one, and maybe info us on the resolution. We all go through learning experiences, maybe even learn something. J |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
a "contract" is "a meeting of two or more minds in agreement"...
doesn't even require a handshake. What you are obligated to is the amount of work you told this guy to do before he took off. There is no question that what he did while you weren't aroung, and without asking, was not part of the original agreement nor warranted in any way. You did not ask him to do an additional $1100 worth of work, plain and simple... When an electrician comes out and says "I'll wire up that outlet for $20" then you *technically* arent obligated to pay $20.50 if he wants to charge you for wire nuts or something. Get a lawyer for cryin out loud. This has been answered fifteen times by amatures and tradespeople alike in this forum. |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Quote a contract?
Chris Birkett wrote:
RicodJour wrote: I had asked the OP a question which went unanswered. It gets to the root of the matter. If the father felt comfortable letting the contractor work unsupervised while he was out of the country, and agreed that additional work needed to be done due to unforeseen conditions, why is the son getting involved? Is he "protecting" his father or just sticking his two cents into something he doesn't understand? The real root of the matter is that he DIDN'T agree to pay for additional work. I don't see how my motivation affects this. You said that your father agreed to one price increase which shows that he understood that things that needed to be dealt with were hidden and not included in the original agreement. You will not get complete information from the son, as it's his opinion that the work was unnecessary and it's only one side of the story. Besides that, he wasn't part of the agreement. Did you wonder why the father didn't tag the son to be the supervision while he was away? Kind of curious, no? I don't understand why this bothers you so much. When did I say the work was unnecessary? Ummm, okay. So the work was necessary or you just haven't decided yet? As it stands, the extra charge has not been justified at all, and the work has not even been completed to satisfaction. Then the man owes you an explanation. It also sounded like you were a little put out that he hadn't completed some of the other small jobs he was supposed to take care of. Obviously he should do what he was supposed to do before he bills you for final payment. If he hasn't completed the work, point this out to him. Release the amount of money for the work that is not under dispute as a sign of good faith and have him sign a lien release waiver. I *was* dealing with the repair people while he was gone, and additional costs were never mentioned. Both my mother and I were readily available to discuss it on any of the several days they were here, and they knew my dad was available by e-mail. Being available and supervising the work are two very different things. We're hearing only one side of the story. You don't have experience in construction, you're unfamiliar with contracts, and you will just confuse the issue. Step aside. Anything else is just meddling. You won't get any definitive answer except this - you are not the one to be negotiating with the contractor your father hired. He started it, he should finish it. R |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Cancelling New Home Purchase Contract | Home Ownership | |||
Roofer Contract Dispute | Home Ownership | |||
Roofer Contract Dispute | Home Repair | |||
Windsor Plywood Scam - Saskatoon | Woodworking | |||
Buyers change loan type and requires amendment to contract | Home Ownership |