Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos
today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
Larry Bud wrote:
Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Most likely the contractor is a close relative of a board member. Check your association's by-laws. Maybe a petition, recall election, or other remedy for a rogue board is provided. You'll have to have at hand a copy of the by-laws when you visit your attorney anyway. |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"What can be done to stop this? "
Have you been to board meetings to voice your opinion? Have you talked to the board members and asked them why they believe this is necessary or how they can cost justify it? There could be more to it than you think, as boards usually aren't too quick to approve things that cause a special assessment, if they can help it. If there is a significant underlying problem, patching will only get you so far. The patched areas are not as strong as the original pavement and will not last as long as the original. At some point, you will have so many patchs that it will have to be addressed. You may be right that it is better to put it off for awhile, if it is in fact only costing $5500 a year to patch and it doesn't look like hell. What do your neighbors think? First thing I would do is find out from a board member or property manager if a contract has already been signed. If it has, from a practical standpoint there isn't much you can probably do to stop it. Virtually every board has the power to undertake this kind of repair. And unless there is something underhanded going on, like self dealing, courts are unwilling to get involved in business decisions, even if a better decision could have been made. If they haven't signed a contract yet, then I'd get a hold of the board members, make your opposition known and get neighbors to the next meeting before a contract is signed. |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
Larry Bud wrote: Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. I agree, sounds like nepitism or similiar. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
On 8 Dec 2005 14:32:28 -0800, "Larry Bud"
wrote: Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Audit the money trail..... consult the local state statues regarding your HOA, run for office or otherwise!. A columnist for our local paper writes about these issues, do you have one? If so contact them. Normally, HOA dues go up with notice, not malfeasants - /\0-0/\ Oren "My doctor says I have a malformed public-duty gland and a natural deficiency in moral fiber, and that I am therefore excused from saving Universes." |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"HeyBub" wrote in message ... Larry Bud wrote: Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Most likely the contractor is a close relative of a board member. Check your association's by-laws. Maybe a petition, recall election, or other remedy for a rogue board is provided. You'll have to have at hand a copy of the by-laws when you visit your attorney anyway. I have seen some of the regs for such a development which forbids legal action by its members : ( Hope yours is not like that. |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"Larry Bud" wrote in message oups.com... Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Other have said something like this. I will try to say it clearer. You need to check your bylaws. What the board is suggesting comes under the term capital expenditures. In my HOA the board is authorized to contract for normal expenditures already approved and to raise the HOA fee IF necessary to cover those expenses. Capital expenditures for new projects requires a 75% majority vote of the entire association or a simple majority where 60% of the members are attending the meeting. The easiest way to vote against a popular concept is to not attend. It is real hard for them to bet 60% of the owners in one place at one time. (BG) Again it all comes down to what your bylaws say. Colbyt |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"Larry Bud" wrote in message
oups.com... Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. 1-800-TonySoprano |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"Larry Bud" wrote in message oups.com... Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. It may be that all of the properties in your association are devalued by the constant problem with potholes. That kind of thing runs off prospective buyers. It may be that they would like to deal with the problem this one time and be done with it. Anyway, I'd suggest talking with the management association and figuring out exactly why they want to spend this much of your money. Maybe you'll agree with their logic - those people are *usually* not out to screw the tenants. If you don't agree with their logic, maybe you can reason with them. Beyond that, maybe you have legal recourse. In my old association, you could vote the board out of office and the bylaws didn't allow a big increase such as you describe without a passing vote from a quorum of the association. Good luck getting the right solution. |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
clipped
What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Most likely the contractor is a close relative of a board member. Check your association's by-laws. Maybe a petition, recall election, or other remedy for a rogue board is provided. You'll have to have at hand a copy of the by-laws when you visit your attorney anyway. That is basicly it. Read your documents. If it is a very unpopular decision, you might be able to recall the board members and elect a new board. Board has a duty to maintain the property. A possible, but very doubtful, out is whether this could be considered a "material alteration" and require consent by a majority of owners and not just board members. Don't feel too bad .. our monthly assessment is $285 every month. No roads to pave ) Read your state statute HOA. Florida has separate statutes for condos and for HOA's. |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
clipped
You need to check your bylaws. What the board is suggesting comes under the term capital expenditures. In my HOA the board is authorized to contract for normal expenditures already approved and to raise the HOA fee IF necessary to cover those expenses. Capital expenditures for new projects requires a 75% majority vote of the entire association or a simple majority where 60% of the members are attending the meeting. The easiest way to vote against a popular concept is to not attend. It is real hard for them to bet 60% of the owners in one place at one time. (BG) Again it all comes down to what your bylaws say. Colbyt In Florida, the board has to maintain the property and can vote any size special assessment. To make a material alteration, it take a majority of owners. The board can maintain or repair the pool on it's own vote. But if they want to put a pool where there is none, that is a material alteration. Board members in Florida can be held personally liable for failing to maintain. If your board is hearing complaints because autos are damaged from hitting pot holes, then the repave is likely justified. |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
On 8 Dec 2005 14:32:28 -0800, "Larry Bud"
wrote: Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Sounds idiotic to me, but idiocy is a requirement for many HOAs. After the board is elected, they get rendition to a foreign country where special agents teach them to be stupid. My friend's condo board in NYC tuck pointed a windowless wall, and then tested it by spraying water on the wall (instead of just waiting for tit to rain.) Now my friend has pealing paint and wet plaster in the bedroom that won't dry. My HOA thinks it has to patch every crack, for legal reasons, even the ones that no one could actually trip on. But they hire cheap workman to do the patches. Remove NOPSAM to email me. Please let me know if you have posted also. |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
On Thu, 8 Dec 2005 17:54:07 -0600, "Mike Dobony"
wrote: "HeyBub" wrote in message ... Larry Bud wrote: Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Most likely the contractor is a close relative of a board member. Check your association's by-laws. Maybe a petition, recall election, or other remedy for a rogue board is provided. You'll have to have at hand a copy of the by-laws when you visit your attorney anyway. I have seen some of the regs for such a development which forbids legal action by its members : ( Hope yours is not like that. I hope not also. I actually sued my HOA to get an affirmative injunction to make them pay the dues on the swimming pool next door. I couldn't afford an attorney, so I did it myself, based on my 2 years in law schoo, and the help of the clerks in the Country Clerk's office. The other side had an attorney of course paid for by the HOA's directors and xxx insurance policy. As badly as I did, you'll do worse without any law school. I did well in the first round but had major trouble in the second. Also I had a clause in the bylaws that seemed toimply they had to pay the dues, and I had evidence they had intentionally miscounted the votes during the intervening election for board memebers.. You don't have that. MY friends in NYC had 2 votes of 9 on their side, and when I left Sunday afternoon, they were expecting two more board members for dinner, at which they were going to try to convince htem to stop water-testing the wall. iirc. With 4 votes, they thought the president of the condo board was a reasonable guy and he would vote with them. I have to check what happend. But I think invitign the board members to dinner, one or two at a time, would be a good idea. You don't have to advertise these invitations to other people, but don't hide or lie about them either. You will be found out. We own our own streets and would like to give them to the county so that they would be responsible, but the county won't take them because there isn't a sufficientyly thick base, iiuc. I don't know if our periodic resurfacing (black top) is doing anything to increase the base, or we'll just own them forever. If it were your board they'd probably want to dig the whole thing up and start all over again. I can't remember what a total repave cost 10 years ago. It was either 10 thousand or a 100 thousand, Must have been 100. About 5 medium length blocks with parking on both sides. Some paving companies just want to sell. Get another opinion from a reputable company or two. Remove NOPSAM to email me. Please let me know if you have posted also. |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
On Fri, 09 Dec 2005 02:08:53 GMT, Norminn
wrote: Florida has separate statutes for condos and for HOA's. Maryland too, although the HOA law is slim and regular corporation law applies when the HOA law is silent. Remove NOPSAM to email me. Please let me know if you have posted also. |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
I also think they are repaving it to help maintain bloated real estate
values in the complex, and Id be OK with it. And this thread is useless without pics. |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
All the more reason not to live in a condo or HOA. I'd rather live in
a tree or a cave.-Jitney |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
According to Larry Bud :
What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Before you go ballistic on them, lawsuits etcetera, _ask_ them why they think they have to do the $225,000 version. If the base is bad enough, without fixing is, your yearly repair costs could easily jump substantially each year as the road gets progressively worse. The breakeven point might be a _lot_ less than 41 years. A poor base can get well beyond a mere $5500 worth of pothole repair per year. Washouts, road collapse, etc. HOAs/condo boards have to pay dues too. They're not going to do something like that without a damn good reason - ie: engineers telling them that the whole road is sinking. -- Chris Lewis, Una confibula non set est It's not just anyone who gets a Starship Cruiser class named after them. |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
clipped
HOAs/condo boards have to pay dues too. They're not going to do something like that without a damn good reason - ie: engineers telling them that the whole road is sinking. The board members I know are penny-wise and pound-foolish. I know people who rely on any sales person as an expert, rather than researching issues. I have seen amazing waste with people who quibble over a bag of fertilizer. |
#19
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"Chris Lewis" wrote in message ... According to Larry Bud : What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Before you go ballistic on them, lawsuits etcetera, _ask_ them why they think they have to do the $225,000 version. If the base is bad enough, without fixing is, your yearly repair costs could easily jump substantially each year as the road gets progressively worse. The breakeven point might be a _lot_ less than 41 years. A poor base can get well beyond a mere $5500 worth of pothole repair per year. Washouts, road collapse, etc. HOAs/condo boards have to pay dues too. They're not going to do something like that without a damn good reason - ie: engineers telling them that the whole road is sinking. Ya they may pay dues but some just listen to the management companies. I sat on a board for 6 months. When I came up with away to stop using $10k a month for water and a way to reduce the landscaping contract from $7500 a month to $2300 a month. You would have thought that I was raping their 15 year old daughter on TV. I solved the problem and moved. |
#20
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
Larry, besides the HOA documents there can be a big impact by state laws.
Since you did not specify the state and did not describe the property, (condo, coop, or individually owned) all the answers that you have so far are meaningless. Charlie "Larry Bud" wrote in message oups.com... Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. |
#21
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"Larry, besides the HOA documents there can be a big impact by state
laws. Since you did not specify the state and did not describe the property, (condo, coop, or individually owned) all the answers that you have so far are meaningless. " Not very likely. Do you know of any state where a condo board is restricted by law from making repairs to the property that they deem necessary? State law typically calls for things like open meetings, access to records and the like, but doesn't get involved in what are business decisions. |
#22
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
|
#23
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
|
#24
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
In article , SQLit says...
"Chris Lewis" wrote in message ... According to Larry Bud : What can be done to stop this? I find it ridiculous that even if there is an underlying problem, the cost to repair the road this year was $5500. At that rate, we could repair the road for 41 years for the cost of replacement. This even assumes that the new road wouldn't even have to have repairs in that time, which is probably impossible. Before you go ballistic on them, lawsuits etcetera, _ask_ them why they think they have to do the $225,000 version. If the base is bad enough, without fixing is, your yearly repair costs could easily jump substantially each year as the road gets progressively worse. The breakeven point might be a _lot_ less than 41 years. A poor base can get well beyond a mere $5500 worth of pothole repair per year. Washouts, road collapse, etc. HOAs/condo boards have to pay dues too. They're not going to do something like that without a damn good reason - ie: engineers telling them that the whole road is sinking. Ya they may pay dues but some just listen to the management companies. I sat on a board for 6 months. When I came up with away to stop using $10k a month for water and a way to reduce the landscaping contract from $7500 a month to $2300 a month. You would have thought that I was raping their 15 year old daughter on TV. I solved the problem and moved. Lemme guess - rock lawn? Banty |
#25
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
clipped
Lemme guess - rock lawn? Banty Outlawed where I live. Florida's only industries, after Diz world, are growing grass and killing bugs ) |
#26
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"Larry Bud" writes:
The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". Um... there is one solution I havn't seen mentioned. Were there specs for the original job? Were they met? Did they include something about doing the job right? Is the original contractor judgement proof? (or was the road preexisting to the development.... didn't sound like it since you said it was only used by your sub.) -- be safe. flip Ich habe keine Ahnung was das bedeutet, oder vielleicht doch? Remove origin of the word spam from address to reply (leave "+") |
#27
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
In article t, Norminn says...
clipped Lemme guess - rock lawn? Banty Outlawed where I live. Florida's only industries, after Diz world, are growing grass and killing bugs ) OK - so, what, exactly, was the improvement in practice that SQLit proposed to his HOA board, to save all that landscaping *and* all that water cost, that caused them to react so horribly? SQLit? Banty |
#28
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
Banty wrote:
In article t, Norminn says... clipped Lemme guess - rock lawn? Banty Outlawed where I live. Florida's only industries, after Diz world, are growing grass and killing bugs ) OK - so, what, exactly, was the improvement in practice that SQLit proposed to his HOA board, to save all that landscaping *and* all that water cost, that caused them to react so horribly? SQLit? If I were cynical (who, me? ) I'd assume it was probably the sweetheart deal w/ the nephew, etc., that wouldn't be renewed that was the cause of the ruckus, not the solution itself... |
#29
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
In article , Duane Bozarth says...
Banty wrote: In article t, Norminn says... clipped Lemme guess - rock lawn? Banty Outlawed where I live. Florida's only industries, after Diz world, are growing grass and killing bugs ) OK - so, what, exactly, was the improvement in practice that SQLit proposed to his HOA board, to save all that landscaping *and* all that water cost, that caused them to react so horribly? SQLit? If I were cynical (who, me? ) I'd assume it was probably the sweetheart deal w/ the nephew, etc., that wouldn't be renewed that was the cause of the ruckus, not the solution itself... Possibly. On the other hand, the Proposal That Saves Big Bucks may be that whole segments of maintenance be blown off for a few years, at least until some time after the Proposer sells, that taking place before the effects of the negligence becomes visible. Seen it. It cuts both ways. My mental red flag gets raised when the proposal is 1. Unspecified to us, and 2. Involves *both* landscaping costs and water costs. Unless someone on the board has cousins both in the water district and the landscaping business?? So I get this "Paul Harvey" what's the "rest of the story" feeling about it. If I'm left to fill in the details all by myself, my guess is - the proposal involved some massive negligence of the grounds. But he can surely post and clarify... Banty (me, I'm so cynical, I don't believe either "side" of much of anything!) |
#30
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
Charlie Bress wrote: Larry, besides the HOA documents there can be a big impact by state laws. Since you did not specify the state and did not describe the property, (condo, coop, or individually owned) all the answers that you have so far are meaningless. I'm in Michigan, and these are site condos. |
#31
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
Philip Lewis wrote: "Larry Bud" writes: The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". Um... there is one solution I havn't seen mentioned. Were there specs for the original job? Were they met? Did they include something about doing the job right? Is the original contractor judgement proof? (or was the road preexisting to the development.... didn't sound like it since you said it was only used by your sub.) The road was part of the development. I learned a few things tonight after making a bunch of calls. Got in touch with the only board member who opposed this thing: 1) There is nothing in the by-laws that state they have to call a special assessment meeting for ANY expense if the money for whatever they want to spend is in the budget for the next year, provided the budget goes out at least 30 days before the year end. The budget was sent out on November 30 (how convenient!). What's really scary about this provision is that the road could have cost 10 million bucks, and they could try to pass this off to us without any approval of the co-owners. 2) A contract has NOT been signed, and the board will have to collect a certain % of money before the contractor will do the work. I don't yet know what % that is, but I believe it is over 50%. This gives us who oppose some time to get a petition going. 3) They waited last year to fix the pot holes that formed to try and sway people into believing the road was really a piece of **** 4) 3 of the board members live on the road that is to be replaced 5) The quote the contractor came up with is not set in stone, as there's a provision that he can change the quote based on oil prices, since asphalt cost goes up as oil goes up. The replacement was supposed to happen in April, which as we all know, the cost of oil generally goes up in the spring/summer because of travel. 6) The whole idea came about from the President of the association, and the VP of the management company. Can someone tell me what relation a management company has to an association? IOW, what do they do for us? |
#32
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"Larry Bud" wrote in message ups.com... Philip Lewis wrote: "Larry Bud" writes: The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". Um... there is one solution I havn't seen mentioned. Were there specs for the original job? Were they met? Did they include something about doing the job right? Is the original contractor judgement proof? (or was the road preexisting to the development.... didn't sound like it since you said it was only used by your sub.) The road was part of the development. I learned a few things tonight after making a bunch of calls. Got in touch with the only board member who opposed this thing: 1) There is nothing in the by-laws that state they have to call a special assessment meeting for ANY expense if the money for whatever they want to spend is in the budget for the next year, provided the budget goes out at least 30 days before the year end. The budget was sent out on November 30 (how convenient!). What's really scary about this provision is that the road could have cost 10 million bucks, and they could try to pass this off to us without any approval of the co-owners. The November 30 thing isn't necessarily a sign of malfeasance. That was their deadline and they met it. I'd argue that it would have been good for the board to have a public discussion of the situation before making such a significant decision. 2) A contract has NOT been signed, and the board will have to collect a certain % of money before the contractor will do the work. I don't yet know what % that is, but I believe it is over 50%. This gives us who oppose some time to get a petition going. 3) They waited last year to fix the pot holes that formed to try and sway people into believing the road was really a piece of **** 4) 3 of the board members live on the road that is to be replaced 5) The quote the contractor came up with is not set in stone, as there's a provision that he can change the quote based on oil prices, since asphalt cost goes up as oil goes up. The replacement was supposed to happen in April, which as we all know, the cost of oil generally goes up in the spring/summer because of travel. 6) The whole idea came about from the President of the association, and the VP of the management company. Can someone tell me what relation a management company has to an association? IOW, what do they do for us? My experience (several years as a board member in a HOA) was that the Management company was supposed to bulldog collections issues, monitor legal issues, report on certain things around the neighborhood (compliance with covenants, for instance), and offer suggestions to the board since the management company should have more collective experience than most HOA boards. In addition, the Management company was supposed to offer a buffer so PO'd homeowners didn't start fistfights in the street with board members. Of course, there is a fee associated with this, and it is substantial. In our association, the Management company did a truly horrible job and we fired them. If all Management companies were as bad as the one we hired, I don't think the management company industry would last very long. |
#33
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
"Can someone tell me what relation a management company has to an
association? IOW, what do they do for us? " The management company works for the association, is hired by the board and manages the day to day operations of the condo. That includes collecting maintenance fees, sending out late notices/fines, paying bills, keeping the books, responding to unit owners requests for info or maintenance, etc, soliciting bids for work that needs to be done, recommending vendors/contractors, verifying work being done by vendors/contractors, periodically inspecting the property and putting up with a lot of abuse |
#34
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
clipped
My experience (several years as a board member in a HOA) was that the Management company was supposed to bulldog collections issues, monitor legal issues, report on certain things around the neighborhood (compliance with covenants, for instance), and offer suggestions to the board since the management company should have more collective experience than most HOA boards. In addition, the Management company was supposed to offer a buffer so PO'd homeowners didn't start fistfights in the street with board members. Of course, there is a fee associated with this, and it is substantial. In our association, the Management company did a truly horrible job and we fired them. If all Management companies were as bad as the one we hired, I don't think the management company industry would last very long. I haven't followed this thread blow by blow, but mgt. companies are worth every nickel. They can do the really unpleasant stuff, but can't make board decisions. Can help keep boards out of legal trouble. That said, the issue in this thread may represent a good decision. In Florida, boards are legally required to maintain the property. Not optional, not based on cost. Potholes obviously represent a maintenance need. At some point it is wise to stop throwing good money after bad and put down a good road. The total $ is big money, but the owner share is far from hardship. It gets real tiresome to have folks coming to the door about maintenance deficits when boards don't do their job. We just fixed a sagging roof - wood beam rotted entirely through - that was held up for years with two sections of downspout. Makes for some good jokes with the contractor crew ) |
#35
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
In addition, the Management company was supposed to offer a buffer
so PO'd homeowners didn't start fistfights in the street with board members. Of course, there is a fee associated with this, and it is substantial. In our association, the Management company did a truly horrible job and we fired them. If all Management companies were as bad as the one we hired, I don't think the management company industry would last very long. Who was the company? What did they do so poorly? |
#36
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
clipped
Can someone tell me what relation a management company has to an association? IOW, what do they do for us? In FL, it is generally on a contractural basis and condo associations contract with them for certain functions. Decision making remains with condo association/board. It can be anything from complete day to day management, effecting repairs and maintenance per approved contractors, acting on complaints, rules violations, assessment arrears. Can even have a licensed condo manager conduct meetings. If the association is large enough, it is probably the only way to go. We have a small assn, only 8 units. Full outside mgt. would be cost prohibitive, so mgt. company pays bills as authorized, keeps books, files taxes, issues some of the meeting and budget letters. State law requires letters to owners at certain intervals prior to board meetings and budget votes. State law also requires that condo assn. maintain financial reserves for roofs, parking lots and painting, but allows owners to vote down reserves - the board cannot vote down reserves AFAIK. FL. statutes are very clear in stating that board members are responsible for maintaining property and can be held personally responsible for not doing so. FL statutes don't define maintenance or any standards, and best answer on the topic is that they maintain according to local building codes. Local gov. doesn't enforce building code, so it is basic free-for-all. |
#37
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quater million bucks
Larry Bud wrote: Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. Just a follow up to this as I get more info: We have started a petition to 1) oppose the increase, 2) call a special meeting (we actually need a certain % of signatures to do this and 3) remove the president of the board. I hit the pavement and talked to 20 people, 19 of which signed the petition, and 1 who was some old cranky guy that told me to "go to hell". Kinda funny. We have found out that the builder had a $500,000 bond for the road. The sub was built 10 years ago. It was told to many of the people (at least this is what many residents that I talked to said... the fact that it came from several independant sources tell me that it's most likely true) that the bond ran out a few years ago, but now we found out that it really ran out 6 months ago! We're trying to figure out who told whom what, and who pushed for the road just now, instead of 2 or 3 years ago when it could have been covered by the bond, and what relationship is between the builder and the management company..... follow the money. |
#38
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quarter million bucks
Larry Bud wrote: Larry Bud wrote: Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. Just a follow up to this as I get more info: We have started a petition to 1) oppose the increase, 2) call a special meeting (we actually need a certain % of signatures to do this and 3) remove the president of the board. Update on this, and advice needed: Enough people complained for them to only raise dues from $75 to $130. We still, however, want to call a special meeting. We have gathered enough sigs to call a special meeting, but the board and management company has refused. They claim that the petition was not binding. In addition, one of the board members have told the others on the board (there are 4 total, there is 1 opening that they have failed to fill) that he signed the petition. They claim that he's in conflict of interest (he IS a co-owner), and they've scared him enough to back down on wanting his name on the peition. He's afraid of a lawsuit. What do we do next short of hiring a lawyer (or getting the hell out of here) when it's clearly spelled out in the by-laws what is required for a special meeting? There is election in April, so maybe we just should wait until then and try to run and get on the board, assuming elections they hold are fair (I wouldn't put it past them that they aren't). |
#39
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quarter million bucks
Some states have rule governing how a Home Owners Association board must
conduct itself. "Larry Bud" wrote in message oups.com... Larry Bud wrote: Larry Bud wrote: Got a letter today from the VP of the Management for our site condos today. Almost every year we have to patch about 1/2 mile or so of road from pot holes. The roads are not heavily travelled, and only used by our sub, and while the pot holes were a nuisance, the road is only 15 mph. The letter states that the board had conferred with several asphalt contrators who have concluded that the road was "originally installed an an incorrect pitch with much of the base comprised of grey wet clay". The board had decided to tear out a good portion of the road, and the estimated cost was $225,000. Our dues are to go up from $75/month to almost $300 from jan to apr, then back down to $80 after that. Just a follow up to this as I get more info: We have started a petition to 1) oppose the increase, 2) call a special meeting (we actually need a certain % of signatures to do this and 3) remove the president of the board. Update on this, and advice needed: Enough people complained for them to only raise dues from $75 to $130. We still, however, want to call a special meeting. We have gathered enough sigs to call a special meeting, but the board and management company has refused. They claim that the petition was not binding. In addition, one of the board members have told the others on the board (there are 4 total, there is 1 opening that they have failed to fill) that he signed the petition. They claim that he's in conflict of interest (he IS a co-owner), and they've scared him enough to back down on wanting his name on the peition. He's afraid of a lawsuit. What do we do next short of hiring a lawyer (or getting the hell out of here) when it's clearly spelled out in the by-laws what is required for a special meeting? There is election in April, so maybe we just should wait until then and try to run and get on the board, assuming elections they hold are fair (I wouldn't put it past them that they aren't). |
#40
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
How to stop an HOA from blowing a quarter million bucks
clipped
Update on this, and advice needed: Enough people complained for them to only raise dues from $75 to $130. We still, however, want to call a special meeting. We have gathered enough sigs to call a special meeting, but the board and management company has refused. They claim that the petition was not binding. In addition, one of the board members have told the others on the board (there are 4 total, there is 1 opening that they have failed to fill) that he signed the petition. They claim that he's in conflict of interest (he IS a co-owner), and they've scared him enough to back down on wanting his name on the peition. He's afraid of a lawsuit. What do we do next short of hiring a lawyer (or getting the hell out of here) when it's clearly spelled out in the by-laws what is required for a special meeting? There is election in April, so maybe we just should wait until then and try to run and get on the board, assuming elections they hold are fair (I wouldn't put it past them that they aren't). First, boards have a LEGAL DUTY (here in Florida, ennyhoo) to maintain the property and have the authority to pass special assessments to do so. IF they have acted in good faith and according to statutes and bylaws, it would be hard to run a legal objection to their action. If your pothole problem is causing damage to vehicles or lots of complaints, it sounds as if they have acted judiciously. They are probably a code violation as well. The amount of increase - $150/month for six months? - sure isn't beyond reasonable for repairs. A petition, by itself, likely would not be legally binding. Florida has separate statutes for HOA's and condominiums. Also has process for arbitration, but that is generally for administrative wrongs (board has not complied with statutes or bylaws), not to take issue with a particular vote. Having enough signatures to call a special meeting doesn't meet muster here, as the board still has the authority to vote for maintenance and repairs, not the association. You may have enough signatures (members to vote) to recall board members, and a new board could then vote down the project (unless contracts already signed). In Florida, the members have to vote if there is a material alteration to the common areas - like installing a new pool - but repairing existing roads would not seem to be a material alteration. Read your documents. Members can always sue here, but in FL the loser pays costs. |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
capacitor or something to provide steady 110V to stop breakers from blowing | Electronics | |||
Threading on a "slow to stop" lathe | Metalworking | |||
electrical interruption | Home Repair | |||
What is it with yellow pine? | Woodworking | |||
safety question - many short cut-offs using a stop | Woodworking |