$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

Craftsman 8.0 amp Reciprocating Saw
Sears item #00917173000 Mfr. model #17173

that's the model and during the black friday thanksgiving sale it's
price is apparantly going to be $49.95. pretty damn cheap. my
question, of course, is whether it's going to be okay for occassional
use or should i just fork over $119 for the cheapest milwaukee?
thoughts?

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

I bought one for occasional use 20 yrs ago, it still works, I cant say
if the quality is the same. but I can say 20 years ago I would blow out
a sears pad sander a day, after 6 or so they refunded my money. If you
are easy on the saw, dont force it, it should last.

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

"flipper" wrote in message
oups.com...
Craftsman 8.0 amp Reciprocating Saw
Sears item #00917173000 Mfr. model #17173

that's the model and during the black friday thanksgiving sale it's
price is apparantly going to be $49.95. pretty damn cheap. my
question, of course, is whether it's going to be okay for occassional
use or should i just fork over $119 for the cheapest milwaukee?
thoughts?

For occasional light use, it should be OK. You wont see one in the tool box
of a pro, but he may use one for hours every week. Most of us at home use
it an hour a year.

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

"flipper" wrote in message
oups.com...
Craftsman 8.0 amp Reciprocating Saw
Sears item #00917173000 Mfr. model #17173

that's the model and during the black friday thanksgiving sale it's
price is apparantly going to be $49.95. pretty damn cheap. my
question, of course, is whether it's going to be okay for occassional
use or should i just fork over $119 for the cheapest milwaukee?
thoughts?



You already have 2 opinions and mine is the same.

Also, who is to say that Milwaukee doesn't make the Craftsman anyway?

If your sales associate is any good, he/she should be able to tell you the
manufacturer. The two digits, if I remember right, after the 009 (division #
for hardware) should be the manufacturer's code telling who it is.

On the box, the # will probably read - 009 17-17300 . The 17 is the
manufacturer code.

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

well, i went out and got it. put the blade for metal in, pulled the
trigger, touched the blade to metal and bingobango the blade snapped
right in half.
put another blade in, tried to go at a piece of wood at a slight
angle, pulled the trigger, felt something wrong, stopped, looked at the
blade and twas bent to one side.
maybe it's the blades?
guess i'll go back and get some bimetal ones. see how they do.....

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

"flipper" wrote in message
oups.com...
well, i went out and got it. put the blade for metal in, pulled the
trigger, touched the blade to metal and bingobango the blade snapped
right in half.
put another blade in, tried to go at a piece of wood at a slight
angle, pulled the trigger, felt something wrong, stopped, looked at the
blade and twas bent to one side.
maybe it's the blades?
guess i'll go back and get some bimetal ones. see how they do.....




That sucks!

Take the blades back and tell Sears that you didn't even get to use them and
you want them replaced...

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

To Sears specs!

On Sat, 12 Nov 2005 17:32:57 GMT, "C. Massey"
wrote:

Also, who is to say that Milwaukee doesn't make the Craftsman anyway?

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

"nospambob" wrote in message
...
To Sears specs!

On Sat, 12 Nov 2005 17:32:57 GMT, "C. Massey"
wrote:

Also, who is to say that Milwaukee doesn't make the Craftsman anyway?


That could be good or bad...

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

On Sat, 12 Nov 2005 12:47:47 GMT, "Edwin Pawlowski"
wrote:

"flipper" wrote in message
roups.com...
Craftsman 8.0 amp Reciprocating Saw
Sears item #00917173000 Mfr. model #17173

that's the model and during the black friday thanksgiving sale it's
price is apparantly going to be $49.95. pretty damn cheap. my
question, of course, is whether it's going to be okay for occassional
use or should i just fork over $119 for the cheapest milwaukee?
thoughts?

For occasional light use, it should be OK. You wont see one in the tool box
of a pro, but he may use one for hours every week. Most of us at home use
it an hour a year.

Agreed. I saw the installer next door using one to take out the old
(1979) window frames, when my neighbor bought new windows. (2 to 5
minutes per window frame -- 3 frames)

But I'm keeping my windows, so I didn't even get my one hour this
year.


Remove NOPSAM to email me. Please let
me know if you have posted also.

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

"flipper" wrote in message
oups.com...
well, i went out and got it. put the blade for metal in, pulled the
trigger, touched the blade to metal and bingobango the blade snapped
right in half.
put another blade in, tried to go at a piece of wood at a slight
angle, pulled the trigger, felt something wrong, stopped, looked at the
blade and twas bent to one side.
maybe it's the blades?
guess i'll go back and get some bimetal ones. see how they do.....


You want the blade and the saw snugged up to the "target" before turning the
saw on....its not a chain sawG......also try to start the saw slowly
(variable speed) until the cut digs in.....otherwise you'll break a bunch of
blades.....Rod

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

Not a bad saw for the price, but its a matter of how much you'll use
it.
I'd buy it and see how well it works. If its 80% plastic, i'd stay
away from it.

I've had pretty good luck with my 99.00 porter cable unit.
I beat it up pretty darn good over the years and it still works
fine. Others mileage may vary.

Tom

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

Also, you're not guaranteed quality with name brand either. I ploughed
down about $120 a few years ago for a Porter Cable reciprocating saw,
I'd say it was used on and off for about 2 years during various home
remodelling projects, one time I went to twist the blade release collar
and everything just fell apart, the collar came off a ball bearing went
missing as did a spring. Unfortunately at $50 for the service center to
just look at it, it made more sense for me to throw $100 at a new
DeWalt.

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

flipper wrote:
well, i went out and got it. put the blade for metal in, pulled the
trigger, touched the blade to metal and bingobango the blade snapped
right in half.
put another blade in, tried to go at a piece of wood at a slight
angle, pulled the trigger, felt something wrong, stopped, looked at the
blade and twas bent to one side.
maybe it's the blades?
guess i'll go back and get some bimetal ones. see how they do.....

The problem is on the end of the saw opposite from the blade. You'll
break more blades till you get that fixed. You fix it through
experience.

Basically, anytime the blade tip encounters an immovable object
head-on, the blade will bend or snap unless it is already sufficiently
buried and supported in the sawcut.

Work as close to the "foot" of the saw as you can, where the blade is
attached to the saw, and you'll decreease the tendency to break blades.
Don't start the saw with the blade way out in the air and then attempt
to bring the blade in contact with the work piece, as you're more
likely to walk the blade out of the cut and jackhammer it. Make light
contact with the work piece first, then squeeze the trigger, and
balance the applied pressure with the saw speed.

Blind cuts where the tip gets buried are the hardest to master.

$50 craftsman reciprocating saw -- opinion?
 

you're right as rain -- a total case of operator error.
since figuring that out, i've done much better.
thanks!