Electronics (alt.electronics)

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Thomas G. Marshall
 
Posts: n/a
Default D-Cell mAh: lithium vs NiMH vs regular alkaline


Questions.

1. I've found online a NiMH D-Cell boasting 11,000 mAh for $9. Can that be
true?

2. The few Li-ion in D-Cell config I've found have pathetic milli amp hours.
Are there any that will last a long time in something like, oh, a baby swing
and/or flashlite?

3. I know that the unused shelf-life of NiMH and cads are pretty bad. But
what of the lithiums? This is important because I'm interested in
flashlight usages too.

Are there any good pointers to D-Cell rechargables (not the old zincs or
lead-acid's)?

Inteded uses:

Baby swing
Flashlights
Radio

4. I know that a regular D-cell (and others) are 1.5 V. Is there a "under
load" consideration that changes specifications for that? What are the amps
of such things. I understand the concepts of volts, amps, amphours, etc.,
but do not understand them as they relate to batteries. Furthermore I've
read that the rechargables typically don't quite reach the 1.5 voltage.


Thanks!

--
Everythinginlifeisrealative.Apingpongballseemssmal luntilsomeoneramsitupyournose.


  #2   Report Post  
Jerry G.
 
Posts: n/a
Default

The largest chargeable battery I have seen in a "D" cell was a rating of
4,000 mAh. This would be 4 Ah. This battery type was an industrial rated
battery primarily for running portable lighting equipment, and
communications equipment. The standard "D" cells that I see are rated at
2,000 mAh. Maybe the battery you saw is really rated at 1,100 mAh, and
they made a printing error?

Take note that most of these chargeable batteries are rated at 1.25 to
1.35 Volts. They are not usually rated at 1.5 Volts. If you are building
a pack to run 12 Volt equipment it would be best to use 10 of these
battery types in series. We have also built packs with 16 of these
batteries in series and put an efficient high current capacity voltage
regulator on its output to regulate the output voltage down to 12.5
Volts. Some customers asked for 13.8 Volts to be equivalent to the same
voltage that can come from the average automobile.

If you want to have more current, you can make up combinations of series
and parallel configurations with these batteries. If we put three sets
in parallel in order to have three times the current capacity. When this
is done, then portability becomes another issue.

The rating of 11,000 mAh for a single "D" cell sounds very high, or this
is battery type I have not seen yet!

--

Jerry G.
======

"Thomas G. Marshall"
. com wrote in message
news:u8f9d.3534$4b.2817@trndny09...

Questions.

1. I've found online a NiMH D-Cell boasting 11,000 mAh for $9. Can that
be
true?

2. The few Li-ion in D-Cell config I've found have pathetic milli amp
hours.
Are there any that will last a long time in something like, oh, a baby
swing
and/or flashlite?

3. I know that the unused shelf-life of NiMH and cads are pretty bad.
But
what of the lithiums? This is important because I'm interested in
flashlight usages too.

Are there any good pointers to D-Cell rechargables (not the old zincs or
lead-acid's)?

Inteded uses:

Baby swing
Flashlights
Radio

4. I know that a regular D-cell (and others) are 1.5 V. Is there a
"under
load" consideration that changes specifications for that? What are the
amps
of such things. I understand the concepts of volts, amps, amphours,
etc.,
but do not understand them as they relate to batteries. Furthermore
I've
read that the rechargables typically don't quite reach the 1.5 voltage.


Thanks!

--
Everythinginlifeisrealative.Apingpongballseemssmal luntilsomeoneramsitupy
ournose.



  #3   Report Post  
Thomas G. Marshall
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Jerry G. coughed up:
The largest chargeable battery I have seen in a "D" cell was a rating
of 4,000 mAh. This would be 4 Ah. This battery type was an industrial
rated battery primarily for running portable lighting equipment, and
communications equipment. The standard "D" cells that I see are rated
at 2,000 mAh. Maybe the battery you saw is really rated at 1,100 mAh,
and they made a printing error?

Take note that most of these chargeable batteries are rated at 1.25 to
1.35 Volts. They are not usually rated at 1.5 Volts. If you are
building a pack to run 12 Volt equipment it would be best to use 10
of these battery types in series. We have also built packs with 16 of
these batteries in series and put an efficient high current capacity
voltage regulator on its output to regulate the output voltage down
to 12.5 Volts. Some customers asked for 13.8 Volts to be equivalent
to the same voltage that can come from the average automobile.

If you want to have more current, you can make up combinations of
series and parallel configurations with these batteries. If we put
three sets in parallel in order to have three times the current
capacity. When this is done, then portability becomes another issue.

The rating of 11,000 mAh for a single "D" cell sounds very high, or
this is battery type I have not seen yet!




http://www.zbattery.com/mh-2d110.html
http://michaelbluejay.com/batteries/
http://thomas-distributing.com/mh-2d110.htm (same as first battery)

The following has them up to 9000mAh, but over 10x the cost of the others!
http://www.megabatteries.com/items.asp?cat_id=63





--
It'salwaysbeenmygoalinlifetocreateasignaturethaten dedwiththeword"blarphoogy".


  #4   Report Post  
Bill Bowden
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"Thomas G. Marshall" . com wrote in message news:u8f9d.3534$4b.2817@trndny09...
Questions.

1. I've found online a NiMH D-Cell boasting 11,000 mAh for $9. Can that be
true?

2. The few Li-ion in D-Cell config I've found have pathetic milli amp hours.
Are there any that will last a long time in something like, oh, a baby swing
and/or flashlite?

3. I know that the unused shelf-life of NiMH and cads are pretty bad. But
what of the lithiums? This is important because I'm interested in
flashlight usages too.

Are there any good pointers to D-Cell rechargables (not the old zincs or
lead-acid's)?

Inteded uses:

Baby swing
Flashlights
Radio

4. I know that a regular D-cell (and others) are 1.5 V. Is there a "under
load" consideration that changes specifications for that? What are the amps
of such things. I understand the concepts of volts, amps, amphours, etc.,
but do not understand them as they relate to batteries. Furthermore I've
read that the rechargables typically don't quite reach the 1.5 voltage.


Thanks!


I haven't seen any 11,000 mAh NiMh batteries, but I have seen
8,000 mAh 'D' cells for 9 or 10 dollars.

A standard 'D' alkaline cell will be about 16,000 mAh and
has a long shelf life. Alkalines are probably better for
the radio if you don't play it all day long. Same goes
for the flashlight if you don't use it much.

I hear recharable Lithium cells have a very long shelf life
(charged) but they may blow up if overcharged. I think the
capacity is about the same as ni-cads.

-Bill
  #5   Report Post  
Jerry Greenberg
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Live and learn! I have never seen a "D" battery at 11,000 mAh.

The largest that the suppliers I deal with can supply is at 4,000 mAh.

Jerry G.
========


(Bill Bowden) wrote in message . com...
"Thomas G. Marshall" . com wrote in message news:u8f9d.3534$4b.2817@trndny09...
Questions.

1. I've found online a NiMH D-Cell boasting 11,000 mAh for $9. Can that be
true?

2. The few Li-ion in D-Cell config I've found have pathetic milli amp hours.
Are there any that will last a long time in something like, oh, a baby swing
and/or flashlite?

3. I know that the unused shelf-life of NiMH and cads are pretty bad. But
what of the lithiums? This is important because I'm interested in
flashlight usages too.

Are there any good pointers to D-Cell rechargables (not the old zincs or
lead-acid's)?

Inteded uses:

Baby swing
Flashlights
Radio

4. I know that a regular D-cell (and others) are 1.5 V. Is there a "under
load" consideration that changes specifications for that? What are the amps
of such things. I understand the concepts of volts, amps, amphours, etc.,
but do not understand them as they relate to batteries. Furthermore I've
read that the rechargables typically don't quite reach the 1.5 voltage.


Thanks!


I haven't seen any 11,000 mAh NiMh batteries, but I have seen
8,000 mAh 'D' cells for 9 or 10 dollars.

A standard 'D' alkaline cell will be about 16,000 mAh and
has a long shelf life. Alkalines are probably better for
the radio if you don't play it all day long. Same goes
for the flashlight if you don't use it much.

I hear recharable Lithium cells have a very long shelf life
(charged) but they may blow up if overcharged. I think the
capacity is about the same as ni-cads.

-Bill



  #6   Report Post  
Thomas G. Marshall
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Jerry Greenberg coughed up:
Live and learn! I have never seen a "D" battery at 11,000 mAh.

The largest that the suppliers I deal with can supply is at 4,000 mAh.

Jerry G.
========



1. Please, if you want to top post, I don't have a real issue with it as
long as others in your quote havn't bottom posted already. Throwing a top
post on top of a buch of bottom posts makes a huge MESS.

2. Did you see the links to the 11,000 mAh's I posted earlier?



--
"His name was Robert Paulson. His name was Robert Paulson. His name was
Robert Paulson..."


  #7   Report Post  
Thomas G. Marshall
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Bill Bowden coughed up:

....[thwack]...


I haven't seen any 11,000 mAh NiMh batteries, but I have seen
8,000 mAh 'D' cells for 9 or 10 dollars.

A standard 'D' alkaline cell will be about 16,000 mAh



Ah ha, thanks! Are they all about the same?

My informal tests between energizer (not e^2) and duracell in the gym
powering my old sony walkman (an excellent low power consumption tape player
by the way) showed me running for OVER A MONTH of EVERY DAY of OVER AN HOUR
A DAY on 2 AA's. No, I am /not/ kidding. Please don't send the cookie
truck, I am not crazy either. The duracells gacked after a week or so.

I asked a duracell spokesman about this and he said that it's possible: the
unadvertised skinny within their (duracell) company is that duracells last
longer on multiple very short term usages than energizer, and that energizer
lasts longer for sustained durations.

HUH? What have you guys found?

....[rip]...


--
"His name was Robert Paulson. His name was Robert Paulson. His name was
Robert Paulson..."


  #9   Report Post  
Watson A.Name - \Watt Sun, the Dark Remover\
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"Jerry G." wrote in message
...
The largest chargeable battery I have seen in a "D" cell was a rating

of
4,000 mAh. This would be 4 Ah. This battery type was an industrial

rated
battery primarily for running portable lighting equipment, and
communications equipment. The standard "D" cells that I see are rated

at
2,000 mAh. Maybe the battery you saw is really rated at 1,100 mAh, and
they made a printing error?


At http://www.cheapbatteries.com/nimh.htm you will see 7000 and 8000 mAh
rechargeable D cells.

[snip]

The rating of 11,000 mAh for a single "D" cell sounds very high, or

this
is battery type I have not seen yet!


I would say that 11,000 isn't unheard of.

--

Jerry G.
======

"Thomas G. Marshall"
. com wrote in

message
news:u8f9d.3534$4b.2817@trndny09...

Questions.

1. I've found online a NiMH D-Cell boasting 11,000 mAh for $9. Can

that
be
true?

2. The few Li-ion in D-Cell config I've found have pathetic milli amp
hours.
Are there any that will last a long time in something like, oh, a baby
swing
and/or flashlite?

3. I know that the unused shelf-life of NiMH and cads are pretty bad.
But
what of the lithiums? This is important because I'm interested in
flashlight usages too.

Are there any good pointers to D-Cell rechargables (not the old zincs

or
lead-acid's)?

Inteded uses:

Baby swing
Flashlights
Radio

4. I know that a regular D-cell (and others) are 1.5 V. Is there a
"under
load" consideration that changes specifications for that? What are

the
amps
of such things. I understand the concepts of volts, amps, amphours,
etc.,
but do not understand them as they relate to batteries. Furthermore
I've
read that the rechargables typically don't quite reach the 1.5

voltage.


Thanks!



Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Lithium Battery Leak! Help! jmonteiro Home Repair 7 July 29th 04 01:35 PM
Ohmwork [email protected] Home Repair 36 July 24th 04 12:22 AM
Substituting NiMH and NiCD for Alkaline? Jason Ducharme Electronics Repair 5 June 4th 04 01:14 AM
NICD vs NIMH batteries [email protected] UK diy 12 January 28th 04 01:09 PM
AA battary capacity, Ah (?) lcoe Metalworking 84 July 23rd 03 04:07 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:47 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"