DIYbanter

DIYbanter (https://www.diybanter.com/)
-   Electronics Repair (https://www.diybanter.com/electronics-repair/)
-   -   Another stupid question (https://www.diybanter.com/electronics-repair/369346-another-stupid-question.html)

[email protected] April 1st 14 08:26 PM

Another stupid question
 
I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".

Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny

William Sommerwerck April 1st 14 08:34 PM

Another stupid question
 
Utter baloney. How can a building absorb energy from a battery?

You just hadn't recharged your cell phone recently.

David Platt April 1st 14 09:15 PM

Another stupid question
 
Utter baloney. How can a building absorb energy from a battery?

You just hadn't recharged your cell phone recently.


A couple of thoughts come to mind:

(1) Cellphones will tend to raise or lower their transmit power when
"talking" to the cell tower, based on signal-strength feedback
from the cell-tower controller. If the hospital building is well
shielded but not entirely radio-opaque, some cellphones might
increase their TX power to stay connected to their network, and
this could run the battery down faster than if they were out in
"clear air".

(2) The nurse might have been making up a story ("save your battery")
instead of saying something like "Please shut down your cellphone,
since we have sensitive electronic equipment in some of the rooms
around here and your phone might interfere with them." She may
have learned that people are more likely to comply with a "turn
the cellphone all the way off" request, if it's excused by a
statement that seems to be in the person's own best interest
("save your battery from being killed").


gareth magennis April 1st 14 09:55 PM

Another stupid question
 


wrote in message
...

I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the
building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses
advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it,
"otherwise the building will kill it".

Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery
state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm
embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to
this? Lenny




I regularly work a 19 hour gig under some railway arches in London. Even
though I have to make sure my phone is fully charged before I enter the
building at 2pm, it is usually pretty much on zero by the time I leave
around 9am.

I believe this is because most of the club has no cellphone signal, but
parts of it does.
So as i wander around, the phone spends most of the time using up its
battery trying to find a signal, polling the transmitter, logging on to the
system when it finds a signal, or whatever it actually does in reality when
it finds itself in such a dire constantly on/off reception situation.

Perhaps your Hospital is similar.


Gareth.


[email protected] April 2nd 14 12:48 AM

Another stupid question
 
Some hospitals these days use wireless monitoring and can be sensitive to interference. As such, many also have shielding on the exterior walls to help reduce that interference. While the phone itself may not be in the frequency range to cause direct problems, its signals will be shielded from the outside which makes the phone search for a signal. This search uses battery power and thus will drain the battery after what appears to be a short time.

Dan

Maynard A. Philbrook Jr. April 2nd 14 03:42 AM

Another stupid question
 
In article ,
says...

I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".

Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


Cell phones may raise the output power if the cell sites they are
receiving all appear to be low in signal. I really think it has much to
do with the model phone you have.

As for the rest of it, be cautions, you may have dementia setting
in! Which makes it easy for people to believe anything! Hell, they
may even believe aliens are flying around above us, right now!

Jamie


[email protected] April 2nd 14 04:48 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Tuesday, April 1, 2014 3:26:05 PM UTC-4, wrote:
I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".



Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


You think they're not? Lenny

Jeff Liebermann April 2nd 14 05:00 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Tue, 1 Apr 2014 12:26:05 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been
in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when
one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my
cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building
will kill it".

Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and
the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it
sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this
just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


True. My guess(tm) is that there's no cell phone signal inside the
building. Your cell phone will continuously transmit at full power
trying to connect to a cell tower that's not there. The algorithm is
stupid and just repeatedly tries to connect until the battery is
depleted. For GSM, the phone does not know which time slot to use, so
it turns the receiver on full time, depeleting the battery even
faster. When we had an area wide fiber outage which killed the local
cell sites, my cell phone battery went from nearly full charge to
totally dead in about 3 hours.

However, you don't have to remove the battery. Just turn off the cell
phone.

--
Jeff Liebermann

150 Felker St #D
http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558

Phil Allison[_2_] April 2nd 14 05:41 AM

Another stupid question
 



I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the
building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses
advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it,
"otherwise the building will kill it".


** Just turning the phone off is enough.

Bet there is no signal in the building and / or they have jammed it.



..... Phil



Jon Elson[_3_] April 2nd 14 08:35 PM

Another stupid question
 
wrote:

I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the
building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses
advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it,
"otherwise the building will kill it".

Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery
state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm
embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to
this? Lenny

My boss has a cell phone that kills the battery in as little as 30 minutes
when he is in our lab. It has a LOT of electronic gear, and is mostly
underground. The phone tries to keep in contact with the cell tower
and needs to crank up the transmitter to full to be heard.

They put microcells around the campus and I think his phone no longer
has this problem.

Jon

[email protected] April 2nd 14 09:45 PM

Another stupid question
 
On Tuesday, April 1, 2014 3:26:05 PM UTC-4, wrote:
I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".



Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


How many watts does a cellphone transmitter output on full power? Lenny

gareth magennis April 2nd 14 09:59 PM

Another stupid question
 


wrote in message
...

On Tuesday, April 1, 2014 3:26:05 PM UTC-4, wrote:
I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the
building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses
advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it,
"otherwise the building will kill it".



Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery
state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm
embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to
this? Lenny


How many watts does a cellphone transmitter output on full power? Lenny




2W for 3G phones.


Gareth.


[email protected] April 3rd 14 12:46 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Tuesday, April 1, 2014 3:26:05 PM UTC-4, wrote:
I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".



Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


That's interesting because I usually keep my phone in my breast pocket. I don't know how I feel about the damn thing irradiating that part of my body at frequencies considered to be just below microwave while continuously stumbling around aimlessly seeking a cell tower just because I'm unfortunate enough to be in a dead spot. Maybe the answer is to just leave the miserable thing off until you really need to use it. Hey people always seemed to be able to find Perry Mason when he was on the road. He was always taking calls on other peoples phones...Lenny

Jeff Liebermann April 3rd 14 01:47 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Wed, 2 Apr 2014 13:45:48 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

How many watts does a cellphone transmitter output on full power? Lenny


Here's the power budget I worked out for proposed Verizon cell site:
http://802.11junk.com/jeffl/coverage/VZW-water-plant/Verizon%20Tower%20Brookdale.xls
With everything turned on full blast, on all frequencies, on all 3
sectors, that's 43,000 watts EIRP.

Of course, it never gets that high because the cell site would
probably blow a fuse or something. Adaptive power control also limits
the handset transmit power to something between 20 to 100 mw into an
antenna with maybe -3dB gain. Cell site transmit is typically in the
same range, but with an antenna with considerably more gain. FCC
rules limit the TX EIRP power to something around 1-3 watts depending
on band. If you drive into the "field test mode" on your handset, you
can see the transmit power level.


--
Jeff Liebermann

150 Felker St #D
http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558

[email protected] April 3rd 14 03:55 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Tuesday, April 1, 2014 3:26:05 PM UTC-4, wrote:
I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".



Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


"Field test mode" sounds very interesting but I doubt that my Motorola Razor has that function. Lenny

Jeff Liebermann April 3rd 14 05:34 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Wed, 2 Apr 2014 19:55:48 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

"Field test mode" sounds very interesting but I doubt that my Motorola Razor has that function. Lenny


Ask, and ye shall receive... (Push and ye shall transmit).

All the Romotola radios have a field test mode:
http://www.wilsonelectronics.com/uploads/docs/FieldTestModes06142010%20wilson004.pdf
http://www.wpsantennas.com/pdf/testmode/fieldtestmodes.pdf
http://www.tessco.com/yts/customerservice/techsupport/datasheets/pdf/FieldTestModes.pdf
There are about 10 different phones with the name RAZR, so you'll need
to be more specific. Be careful as you can easily brick the phone if
you punch the wrong buttons.



--
Jeff Liebermann

150 Felker St #D
http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558

[email protected] April 3rd 14 04:45 PM

Another stupid question
 
On Tuesday, April 1, 2014 3:26:05 PM UTC-4, wrote:
I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".



Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


The phone is an old Razor with Cingular markings on it. A friend had this in his drawer for years and wasn't using it anymore. He gave it to me to replace my Razor that had hit the pavement one too many times. I used the old ATT Sim card in the Cingular phone. On boot it comes up with Cingular logos but works fine on the ATT network. The model number, (I think this is what you need to identify the phone) is: V3(G8/9/18/19). I don't know what all those number mean, perhaps you do. There are several more numbers. I can post them also if need be. Thanks, Lenny

JosephKK April 6th 14 04:32 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Tue, 1 Apr 2014 12:26:05 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".

Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


Insufficeint data.

?-)

JosephKK April 6th 14 04:33 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Tue, 1 Apr 2014 13:15:50 -0700, (David Platt)
wrote:

Utter baloney. How can a building absorb energy from a battery?

You just hadn't recharged your cell phone recently.


A couple of thoughts come to mind:

(1) Cellphones will tend to raise or lower their transmit power when
"talking" to the cell tower, based on signal-strength feedback
from the cell-tower controller. If the hospital building is well
shielded but not entirely radio-opaque, some cellphones might
increase their TX power to stay connected to their network, and
this could run the battery down faster than if they were out in
"clear air".

(2) The nurse might have been making up a story ("save your battery")
instead of saying something like "Please shut down your cellphone,
since we have sensitive electronic equipment in some of the rooms
around here and your phone might interfere with them." She may
have learned that people are more likely to comply with a "turn
the cellphone all the way off" request, if it's excused by a
statement that seems to be in the person's own best interest
("save your battery from being killed").



+2

?-)

JosephKK April 6th 14 04:40 AM

Another stupid question
 
On Wed, 2 Apr 2014 16:46:40 -0700 (PDT),
wrote:

On Tuesday, April 1, 2014 3:26:05 PM UTC-4, wrote:
I had a procedure done in a hospital this morning and I had been in the building for about 30 minutes before we started, when one of the nurses advised me to remove the battery from my cell phone because as she put it, "otherwise the building will kill it".



Perhaps it was coincidence but I then looked at my phone and the battery state of charge was in the toilet. I know it sounds crazy, and I'm embarrassed to even ask, was this just bull**** or is there anything to this? Lenny


That's interesting because I usually keep my phone in my breast pocket. I don't know how I feel about the damn thing irradiating that part of my body at frequencies considered to be just below microwave while continuously stumbling around aimlessly seeking a cell tower just because I'm unfortunate enough to be in a dead spot. Maybe the answer is to just leave the miserable thing off until you really need to use it. Hey people always seemed to be able to find Perry Mason when he was on the road. He was always taking calls on other peoples phones...Lenny



Hmmph, he kept his secretary (Della Street) informed of his whereabouts
and the phone number there.

?-)

Michael A. Terrell April 11th 14 07:35 AM

Another stupid question
 

josephkk wrote:


wrote:

Hey people always seemed to be able to find Perry Mason when he
was on the road. He was always taking calls on other people's
phones...Lenny


Hmmph, he kept his secretary (Della Street) informed of his
whereabouts and the phone number there.



Or Gertie, the switchboard operator when Miss Street was with him. :)


--
Anyone wanting to run for any political office in the US should have to
have a DD214, and a honorable discharge.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:43 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 DIYbanter