View Single Post
  #32   Report Post  
Posted to alt.electronics,alt.home.repair,alt.sci.physics,uk.d-i-y
NY NY is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,863
Default How can you possibly fall off a self balancing scooter?

"Steven" wrote in message
...
"NY" wrote in message
o.uk...
Let's say you're stood stationary and upright on it, not moving. Now,
you lose your balance a little and begin to fall over backwards. Your
feet tilt backwards, the device senses this, and moves backwards.
You're now still over the device

Yes, but it can't move under the center of gravity while your feet are
still on it.


You've forgotten Newton 3: "for every action, there is an equal and
opposite reaction".


Nope.

It moves the wheels by the motor exerting a torque on them. This causes
an equal and opposite torque on the scooter-and-human,


Yes.

thus moving the person's C of G relative to the axle


Nope, because the tilt of the human doesn't change much.


Doesn't it? I've never really watched one in operation that closely.

until the C of G is once again directly over the axle.


Fraid not.

This is how it corrects for the person leaning too far forwards or
backwards.


No, it applies force, it doesn't shift the CoG.

If the person leans back, the sensors detect that the scooter is tipping
backwards, and rotates the wheels backwards, thus tipping the person
forwards.


By force, not by moving the CoG


You may well be right: by exerting a forward-twisting force it may
counteract the tendency of the person (whose C of G is still behind the
axle) to twist the platform backwards. I suppose the fact that it does this
allows the person then to move to adjust their own C of G once the platform
is stable again.