DIYbanter

DIYbanter (https://www.diybanter.com/)
-   Metalworking (https://www.diybanter.com/metalworking/)
-   -   OT how do i tell if pewter has lead in it? (https://www.diybanter.com/metalworking/122655-ot-how-do-i-tell-if-pewter-has-lead.html)

Laszlo Nemeth September 29th 05 10:07 PM

OT how do i tell if pewter has lead in it?
 
just trying to keep a child safe (but its a cool
little figurine).



laz

Richard J Kinch September 29th 05 10:17 PM

Laszlo Nemeth writes:

just trying to keep a child safe (but its a cool
little figurine).


Lead check swaps at any paint store or Wal-Mart.

But hard to believe leaded pewter would dose a kid in any event. Be
reasonable.

woodworker88 September 29th 05 10:36 PM

Lead is only an issue if the dust is inhaled or ingested. So unless
you are planning to be machining the pewter, you should be fine. More
of an issue are antique cast toys with flaking paint that freqently
contains lead or heavy metals.


Laszlo Nemeth September 29th 05 10:53 PM

Richard J Kinch wrote:
Laszlo Nemeth writes:

just trying to keep a child safe (but its a cool
little figurine).


Lead check swaps at any paint store or Wal-Mart.


ok. will they pick up lead in anything?

But hard to believe leaded pewter would dose a kid in any event. Be
reasonable.


local case of lead poisoning a couple years back was
traced to a pewter keyfob a kid was playing with (maybe
sucking on i dunno). As for reasonable, she won't even
notice them missing unless i give them back ;-) or she
finds them in the garage next time we take something apart.


laz

Richard J Kinch September 30th 05 12:24 AM

Laszlo Nemeth writes:

Lead check swaps at any paint store or Wal-Mart.


ok. will they pick up lead in anything?


So sez the package. The newspaper here did a review and they had a lot of
false positives, too.

But hard to believe leaded pewter would dose a kid in any event. Be
reasonable.


local case of lead poisoning a couple years back was
traced to a pewter keyfob a kid was playing with ...


This also begs skepticism.

Laszlo Nemeth September 30th 05 11:03 PM

Richard J Kinch wrote:
Laszlo Nemeth writes:

Lead check swaps at any paint store or Wal-Mart.


ok. will they pick up lead in anything?


So sez the package. The newspaper here did a review and they had a lot of
false positives, too.


great. where there any they recomended?

But hard to believe leaded pewter would dose a kid in any event. Be
reasonable.


local case of lead poisoning a couple years back was
traced to a pewter keyfob a kid was playing with ...


This also begs skepticism.


http://healthyamericans.org/news/index.php?NewsID=267

search on pewter in this article (near the middle)

http://www.sportscurmudgeon.com/archives/sc31.html

i guess my memory isn't as bad as i thought (no lead
poisoning for me (which is a supprise)), since i
half remembered a news story from 5 years ago.


laz

DeepDiver October 1st 05 01:19 AM

"woodworker88" wrote in message
oups.com...
Lead is only an issue if the dust is inhaled or ingested. So unless
you are planning to be machining the pewter, you should be fine.



One other issue I can think of are food containers (e.g., coffee cups,
plates, bowls, etc.) with lead-based glazes. The lead can leach out,
particularly when the item in question contains acidic foods (like tomato
sauce). While I doubt any US manufacturer of kitchen products uses leaded
glazes, I'm not so sure about foreign manufacturers (and it seems these days
that virtually ALL consumer products are now made overseas or in Mexico). I
would have thought that the FTC would prohibit the entry of lead-glazed
products, but apparently such is not the case: in a store the other day, I
saw a sign near some glazed kitchenware that stated "Products marked with a
[yellow triangle symbol, IIRC] contain lead."

The other item that gets the (now ubiquitous) "State of California has
determined that the following may cause cancer..." warning is leaded crystal
(e.g., decanters). Does anyone know how much lead can leach out of leaded
crystal into, say, red wine (which is fairly acidic)?

Or is all this simply more junk science perpetrated by the fear mongers (and
class action lawyers)?

- Michael



Jeff R October 1st 05 01:48 AM


"Laszlo Nemeth" wrote in message
...
just trying to keep a child safe (but its a cool
little figurine).



laz


Hi Laz.

A specific gravity test is very easy (provided that the figurine is not
hollow.)

http://mendosus.com/sg.html

Lead-free pewter should read very close to 7.7
Lead itself is 11.34

Thusly, any reading above 7.7 would suggest lead content.
Usual caveats if the figurine is painted.

It *really* is easy, and accurate. Do some tests on known alloys to prove
this to yourself.

--
Jeff R.



Richard J Kinch October 1st 05 03:33 AM

Laszlo Nemeth writes:

This also begs skepticism.


http://healthyamericans.org/news/index.php?NewsID=267


More ungrounded paranoia.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 DIYbanter