Thread: Balancing a fan
View Single Post
  #8   Report Post  
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
Karl Townsend Karl Townsend is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,286
Default Balancing a fan


"Don Foreman" wrote in message
...
On Fri, 14 May 2010 10:02:20 -0500, "Pete C."
wrote:


Karl Townsend wrote:

I got so much help on my sprayer, I'm trying again...

Full time investigation and part replacement has me working on this
theory
of the problem cause: The squirrel cage fan is out of balance. It is
barely
detectable because the fan has a 2" solid steel shaft and some serious
pillow block bearings mounted solid to a beefy frame. At the resonate
RPM,
this imbalance feeds on the slack in the drive line. Any system upset
causes
the fan to become unstable and it lurches back and forth.

I've called around and not found a place to dynamic balance something
like
this. Are there any home brew methods? Or other suggestions? Its built
so
solid I don't think I'm looking for a minor imbalance.

Karl


Remember that any vibration would relate to the rotational speed of the
item out of balance. Can you get your hands on a resonant reed
tachometer? The RRTs are recommended for isolating vehicle driveline
vibrations by identifying the frequency of the vibration so you can
correlate it to which driveline components rotate at that frequency.

As for fan balance, if you just take the drive belts off you should be
able to turn the fan by hand to identify any issues. Mark the fan and
spin it by hand a few times and see if it is stopping near the same
orientation each time.
Again, I doubt it's the fan since I expect it's spinning a lot faster
than the 540 RPM PTO and won't have a 9 Hz period if it has an
imbalance.


I agree. I also don't see how fan imbalance would generate torque
ripple. I would suspect some aspect of the drive line between PTO and
gearbox: pulley, bent shaft, any couplings or U-joints, etc


Pete and Don, I also agree. I've said it CAN'T be the fan vibration for
years. But I also can't find anything else wrong. And its not for a lack of
trying. I'm about to pop $11,100 and trade it in for a new used one.
Julie's not to keen on that idea, but only because we haven't got the money.


karl